I like it so far. Strong elements of Kay, huh? That just makes me even more eager to read it (Kay is my favorite version, after all). Update soon, please!

dont know if your contiuning, but please do...i loved it so far...not that big on Raoul/Christine, and want to get to Erik/Christine, please longer chapters!

Please say you haven't abandoned this... it's too good to abandon! At least as good as The Rose and the Nightingale. Please update!

I have to say I like this quite a bit. I ship both R/C and E/C. So I can really enjoy this. Very nice. Hope to see more soon.

That was amazing! Can't wait for chapter 3!^-^

Nicely done. I do think Raoul is a sweet man, he loves Christine,that can't be ignored can it? And Emmy and Patrick do make a nice little couple. Sorry gang. But I understand, he's just not our Erik. Keep it rolling sister!

Heh. woot! Another story to look forward to! And you'd better finish this one. *stern look* I saw all of the discontinued fics. It's definitely a trend, which is quite alright b/c I've had that problem myself. There are tons of ideas but, in my case, I run out of inspiration, or I'm just plain lazy. *wink* Anyway, I look forward to the next chapter. Update soon!

Stupid FanFiction won't sign me in anymore... -huffs-

ANYway. I like it even more than I did the first time I reviewed. I don't at all mind the Christine and Raoul stuff--I am purely for her being with Erik, but, if it were not there, it would seem foolish. She and Raoul WERE in love, even if I think that it was some kind of silly, immature love.

.. The POINT was, good job, I'm (still) looking forward to more.

Yes Raoul is not bad but I still prefer Erik.
Meg would suit Raoul fine!. Keep writing!

Well, I must say that I'm disappointed that Christine was into Raoul as well as he into her. I've never really found him to be evil though, so I'm glad you're not doing the Raoul bashing (though it can be fun!). He was sweet, I just think Christine belonged with Erik. Please bring Erik soon! A couple things I thought I'd point out, wen you say 'loosing' that means the act of loosening something, I think you mean 'losing' as in 'lose, lost,etc...' and when you call Raoul 'Viscount' it's a bit distracting as he's actually the 'Vicomte de Changny' in French. But I love the story and am so please with it. I find it very, very realistic. Best wishes, Antoinette

Even though there's no Erik I'll give you the benefit of the doubt and wait anxiously for their first meeting. Well at least Raoul and Christine arn't married it always lowers E/C relationships when she is married! Have to agree completely that Gerry and Emmy look fantastic together- which is always a plus! Keep writing and everything will be great. Fx

I hope that Erik shows up soon. Maybe in the next chapter? I'm an EC worshipper, and I have a friend who is a RC worshipper. We're not really talking at the moment. Keep writing!

I am an EC fan, but I don't mind this at all, its refreshing to read a believable Raoul portrayal. Good hob on this, I really felt for the two of them (and feeling for Raoul is hard for me, hehe) Please update soon!

i am currently without side in the couples debate, it came off well from what i can see, post more soon though, and longer chapters too please!

Why is Christine unhappy? I like the story so far, and I like the concept over all. Can't wait to read more!