 Meenee126 2009-07-01 . chapter 1Holy crap that was amazing! |
 Lucky's Girl 2008-12-21 . chapter 1Hi,
Oh, I loved the story! I wish you had made it into a full story, I love this pairing. I agree they didn't get enough time in the book. I loved how you went through everything that hapend to then. The love, hate, grief, anger, resentment, rejoining, love, understanding, and sacrifice. I adore it so much, you did a spectacular job with it, Yay you! I hope you make other Marisa/Asriel stories! Thanks for a great story!
~Paige |
 7e1 2008-05-13 . chapter 1This is so fantastic, and I read your other one, Adulterers, at your LJ, which is even more fantastic. PLEASE write more Marisa/Asriel, you are so talented at it. |
 Rice Bunny 2008-04-14 . chapter 1Astounding. Truely amazing. |
 Erin Hess 2008-01-13 . chapter 1That was some seriously good work. These are my favorite books in the world and I always want to know more. This is so good that I think Phillip Pullman could've written it himself and put it in the books and It would've made it even better thatn it already is. I like the last segment, amazing really amazing because that's alot like I imagined it.
Nice work! |
 Lizet M 2007-12-05 . chapter 1Damn. I read up until the last three parts...because I haven't read the last book (I still haven't finish the second XD)... but what I read was PERFECT!
I promise to review again once Ive read all three books and those last three parts. :D |
 ZaraShade 2007-08-29 . chapter 1omg that was great. I like that it was broken up and from when they first met all the way to their deaths. I loved it. |
 Feistee 2007-07-10 . chapter 1I completely agree. Their relationship fascinates me as well, and I really would have enjoyed some more focus on them in the books. Excellent Marisa/Asriel fiction, in a fandom that does not seem to have quite enough of it. |
 Palomino Viper 2007-05-07 . chapter 1WOOHOO! love this! |
 Pandora of Ithilien 2007-02-28 . chapter 1excellent. asriel and marisa are two of my favorite literary couples. i mean, they're just so... not quite evil, but not good guys either. i wish there was more about them on the site, or in the books. out of curiosity, what exactly does 10X100 format mean? |
 Figurine 2007-01-02 . chapter 1Finally: a good Lord Asriel and Mrs Coulter fic.
It almost made me cry...
I read this story some time ago and spent two days trying to track it down again in order to review it.
I thought it was fantastic...and very well written. No typos or anything. Rare to find, that.
You did them justice, which is very hard to do.
Everything was in character. Wow.
Thank you! |
 StopTheWorldImGettingDizzy 2006-11-30 . chapter 1That was absolutely perfect.
I just finished TAS and I was so moved by their final scene. Asriel and Marisa are my favorites. You pretty muched summed up how I feel about them in your authoress's note. I always wanted to read more about them, and I came on here hoping to find something. I was so disappointed to find that not only was there very little, but so much of it was an utter insult to these two brilliant characters.
This fic was exactly what I was looking for. I can say confidantly that it is the best marisa/asriel fic I've read, having explored thoroughly. Not that there is much competition, but this was just wonderful. Both of them were in character completely, and each scene stood out vividly and beautifully, and I could see them before my eyes.
I've probably rambled enough, but I just wanted to let you know as best I could how amazing it was for me to find this fic. Thank you for writing it. |
 Lady Game 2006-08-02 . chapter 1Hi! I read this absolutely *ages* ago, and I thought I'd written a review but it turns out I hadn't.
I really like this piece. I'm more in the HP fandom but I love HDM, and this is just brilliant. You chose really insightful scenes from their relationship to write, and wrote it brilliantly. It's amazing how much you can get out of so few words, and how well you integrate the scenes with canon so that you fic and the books complement each other. Nice work!
~*Lady*~
PS - just wondering, did you make up the 10x100 format? Because if you did, I'm sorry - I sort of ripped it off. I thought it was a sort established format but I've never seen anything else written in it. |
 Cosmic Mewtwo 2006-07-06 . chapter 1Wonderful. I always loved the parts about Asriel and Marisa in the books, and I agree with you completely-- it never seemed to be enough. I've wondered, too.
I adored this, really. You have a lovely style, and you managed to keep them perfectly in character. |
 Ieyre 2005-08-01 . chapter 1Gorgeous. The perfect ten moments to write about--all done beautifully. You're right, they DO deserve more time in the books. Their bits are my favs ^_^.
Hopefully we'll get to learn about their first meeting in "The History of Dust". |