Very well written and extremely moving, especially for someone who HAS lost someone close. I could really identify with Ron at the end.
That said, I'm glad you ended the real story differently!

I really don't know what to say, but anyway this story is brilliant, even if it's very sad. It's good to read a story where all the people don't just finish been safe and totaly happy, because in life death is a reallityand so people do die.
Thanks a lot for writting this masterpiece.

Okay, you know that review I did for the other story? The one where I said I almost cried?

Well congrats. I'm currently using up all the Kleenex's in my house.

*bawls*

THIS WAS AWESOME BUT SO SAD.

I think I might prefer it this way though, I dunno...

I like the other ending better. This one was way more sad!! I cried! That is a big deal because I never cry in anything. I want Harry to live! :( That's why, in my mind i am going to pretend I never read this and only remember the other ending. Good story! You are my favorite author! Luv you!

This made me cry so hard!! Esp as I read it while listening to Decode...

Please keep writing - though no more Harry-dying! :) Thanks so much!

I can't believe you made me cry! I almost never cry over fanfics! This was a great alternative ending (though, personally, I'm glad you went with the happier one in the real fic.)

Ron's monologe was heart breaking. I'm crying. I've never cried in a fanfic before. I hate you.

Not really. Really well written...pain-stakenly beautiful...but...I LIKE THE OTHER END BETTER!

OK I made a mistake. I read the alternate ending first despite all of your warnings. That was one well written and thoroughly depressing story. So, I had to go back and read them in order.

If anyone has not read A Hero, Claustrophobia or Family Night by Celebony make sure you do. I am making my way steadily through all of the stories now and have not been disappointed with a single one of them.

Melverne

that was kind of beautiful. very nice ending. very magical in a non-magical sense. i just wish we would've seen harry actually interacting with his parents. you nearly made me cry!

Hi; I just finished reading the alternate ending. It was pretty good, and I was crying.
You've done such a good job on writing this fan fic series.
So apparently you WILL read this; as you mentioned at the end and previously, it was sort of obvious, now i cant believe i actually thought that you only read the reviews during the time you were posting.
Man, this fan fic touched my heart.
Whew.
Im going to go back to checking out other fan fics by you.
(P.S. I cant remember if I used either Anonymous or CreativeGirl for writing my reviews. But In Recnac I used Anonymous; so you know who I am. But Im using CreativeGirl from now on, not Anonymous, so you know who I am. That was sort of wordy wasnt it? :)

How could you...

You made me cry. The screen is all blurry! I NEVER cry over these things. Ever. Maybe once, or twice, in canon (See Death: Sirius, Dumbledore, Fred, Tonks, Remus). But not fanficiton. Ever!

...Until I read Recnac. And this.

Wah! God damnit, there goes my record.
Figured I should really let you know.

Do you think it's funny to make me cry like that? Now I have to read something where Harry is alive or I'm going to have a breakdown... Ok, Ok your story was wonderful I have to say... But god I've cried so much! That's just too sad! You're an amazing athor and you made me feel everything that is possible to feel just with the last part. So now I'm going to wipe my tears away, eat ice cream, listen to some very happy music, walk in my room for a bit and re-read the true ending of Recnac so I can forget about this unhappy, but then again, wonderful one.

With love

A very disturbed Pinkcow

P.S : Let me know if you read my review with a little e-mail if you can :)It's makes me feel good...

I can hardly seethe screen I'm crying so much. Evil!

*sobsob* this is really sad but amazing at the same time!! i love it!!

So SAD! I'm nearly crying. I hope you'll make something showing Harry's life in the afterworldy place. And what happened to Voldecreep.

That was so so so so so so so so so SAD