Share/Save/Bookmark
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Reviews For: A Pirate is a Pirate - Reviews: Page 1 of 2

sakurabender
2008-07-26
ch 9,
abuseGreat story... I thought Luffy's Father was Monkey D. Dragon. It says so in the anime. I'm confused now.
LuffysAngel
2007-08-30
ch 9,
abuseI loved it.
Valdhery
2007-01-13
ch 9,
abuseWell, well, that was a nice tale ! It doesn't follow exactly what happens in the manga/anime, but well, that's AUs for you. There's one thing I don't get though, that's how Luffy and Ace can have black hair if both their father and mother had red hair ?
But I loved it - lots of Shanks and everything.
Valdhery
2007-01-13
ch 5,
abuseMouhahaha ! The more I read, the more I like ! Poor Shanks, really... (not to mention, the scar thing was actually Yasopp's fault... lol). I bet Shanks' gonna be massacred by Marina when she sees Luffy, teehee.
Valdhery
2007-01-13
ch 3,
abuseWush I love this ! *eyes filled with stars* Shanks and Ace and... everything I like ! And I think you stuck pretty close to the characters' personnality. Ok, gotta read next chapter :D
Fishheads
2006-10-02
ch 9,
abuseWE!
Captain-Hina's-Love-Slave
2006-07-05
ch 9,
abuseWow... I can't believe I never read this fic before - it's brilliant! You've given Ace and Luffy a really plausible background, and explained Shanks' connection to them so well, it could almost be part of the series. Though I personally prefer to believe Shanks isn't related to them (I'm not sure why, but there you go). And here's some MAJOR nitpicking - Buggy tells us that Shanks has always worn a straw hat. You may ignore that if you like - it's the sort of scrutiny I subject my own work to, which is why it sometimes takes me ages to write anything. I think you write Ace best - bless him, what a lovely little boy! And you do Shanks extremely well too. You seem to be one of those fairly rare writers who does those two in character, rather than going down the predictable old route of just writing about how cool they are, and how well they fight. I will definately be reading your other fics!
Inumaru12
2006-03-29
ch 3,
abusethat rocked!
The.Adventures.Of.Me
2006-03-10
ch 3,
abuseGreat story! So great, i have to fave. it!
WhiteIcePhoenix
2005-12-16
ch 3,
abuseBRILL! AWESOME!OUT OF THIS WORLD!!
I FAV YOU IMMEDIATLY!
Sweet-single
2005-04-29
ch 3,
abuseCUTE!^_^
I LOVE THIS FIC!!too bad its ended now
Griever5
2005-04-21
ch 3,
abuseI really liked this fic. It flowed along SO WELL with the original story and could have actually been true. I really like the way Ace acted.. hahah... he kept falling asleep!! *thumbs uo* Write more!
NinjaMatty
2005-04-17
ch 3,
abuse*cries* poor marina's dead u_u
That was a so good chapter and the whole fict was very good. I really liked it. Good job =D
Summer eves
2005-04-16
ch 1,
abuseA MASTERPIECE!
Eikou
2005-04-08
ch 2, anon.
abuseWonderful, really. I really like the way you're telling the story with everyone involved, even their mom. Please continue it- I really like it.
Return to Top