Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Search
Reviews for: A Grand Idea
GSYH 11/7/03 . chapter 1
A good read. The circumstances of this fic, while humourous, is still realistic in the GW universe, and the characters are in character, good job.

I like how you did the humour, it's not out of its way overdone, but a mature air the quailty of a bunch a grown women having conversations while fixing their lipstick in front of the bathroom mirror. I meant that in a good way, ladies's room conversations are always amusing and informative, it's during one of them I learned a new way of twisting up my hair. Female bonding.

Catherine and Rashid is a strange idea, but I can see it happening the way you portraited it. And Rashid would do it the old fashion way.
Lothar 12/26/02 . chapter 1
Scary snake, sappy 3X4 goodness, girlie fun. I would call this a good benchmark for short comedy fics. _
Ysabet 9/30/01 . chapter 1
Oh my gods, that was funny! Thank you... I'm in major GW-mode right now (gonna do a second Yami No Matsuei/GW crossover fic, bizarre ne?) and I'm reading tons of GW stuff- but this has got to be the best I've read today! Mucho thankees, and I can see how it won a fic contest! (Doesn't it feel GREAT when that happens?)
Nova of Mink 7/7/01 . chapter 1
LOL, that was cute.
Catwho 6/27/01 . chapter 1
Actually, yes. There is a hentai 1X2 spinoff to this called "Retrospect." It starts Izzy, the dead iguana . . . and it's actually a Relena and Hilde POC fic. Yes, I'm sick. o_O
Wing 6/27/01 . chapter 1
That as Hilarious!...Dorothy...I knew she was fishy! Anyway, is there more? or the end?
Shinigami-chan 5/17/01 . chapter 1
loved it
Ezekiel Klitiras 5/16/01 . chapter 1
That was good. I like it.
SharonToggle 4/11/01 . chapter 1
LOL! That's really funny! Good job! Nice Fic!
may 4/2/01 . chapter 1
Totally loved this fic! Dorothy is really a wiz so she is so much in character! Hope you will make more!
Phelan 3/21/01 . chapter 1
Oh, who would've thought that twigbrows would be such a prankster? Hey Duo, someone's trying to take your title as the Grand Prankster! ::Duo runs in:: "Huh, who?" "Would you believe me If I told you it was Dorothy?" "NOOO! KISAMAAA!" ::Duo drags a startled Wufei in, reches behind him and pulls out the katana from hammerspace:: "I hate to quote Wuffie, but... INJUSTICE!" "Well, I gotta say I liked it. I hope you write one about Dorothy getting Catherine. BWAHAHAHA!
superembarrassed 3/20/01 . chapter 1
That was funny! _
marle 3/19/01 . chapter 1
hilarious fic! with all the right couples.
Euterpe1014 3/18/01 . chapter 1
wow, i really have to check out more of your fics- they have just the right amount of humor in them to make them enjoyable without being too silly...i like what you did with dorothy's character- in my book, it's ok to make her the villian as long as it's all in good fun...and i'm glad you didn't try to force quatre and trowa together with anyone else- it just wouldn't make any sense...congratulations! you're getting me to read non-yaoi (or semi-non-yaoi) and enjoy it!
Return to Top