I absoutly love this story! I first read it all the way back in 2007, and it took me this long to find it again. It is the best Azkaban fic i have every read.
Emme
XX

Love the story, Hope you'll update ASAP!

Like this a lot :D:D and I am extremely glad that you decided on no romance ^^ I did feel that it wouldn't fit into the story :D

Really unique twist on the Harry goes to prison story. Very well done.

So the problem with apathy is that its boring. I like your later stories much better, they capture interest more effectively. Not to say it is badly written, I just feel largely apathetic towards it ;-)

Overall good. The biggest weakness I see is in the setup. His friends would not have abandoned him so easily. Well I don't think Hermione would have at least and I'd tend to think she could have brought Luna and Neville along as well with very little effort. While I don't see Harry always ending up with Hermione, the idea of her and Ron still boggles the mind. The headmaster allowing him to be sent to Azkaban for so long seemed odd as well.

Beyond that the plot is similar to a few others, save usually Harry saves the people who deserve saving as well. Still, this was fairly nicely done.

I don't understand Albus. Wasn't he the one who wanted Harry in prison, the one who put pressure on Neville and co., the one who could've prevented the whole thing if he so chose, the one who could've visited Harry more often if he wanted, the one who could've brought the matter to the new minister... and yet, here he is, very obviously siding and defending Harry.

Awesome. I love phoenix Harry. One of the best versions.

Apathy is indeed a wonderful thing.

Great story would have been nice to see harry and tonks get togeather tho :)

Wow, I really hated Malfoy in this. Rapeing his own mother.

Anyway, I normally don't go for anything that isn't slash but I have to say I loved your story. It was very well written and a good twist on the 'Harry goes to Azkaban' plot.

well done story. thank you.

the end here sounded interesting. It was sad that there was really no dialogue but just summarizing. Made it feel rushed.

This was an interesting story. I can tell that your writing has improved significantly in the 4 years since you wrote this. It is interesting to compare this to your more recent works and observe the improved quality of your exposition and descriptions.

I look forward to reading the sequel.

i never got this. why dont the idiot wizards just use a truth potion. idiots the lot of them!