What a beautiful, sad story. The telling the same events from both points of view is very effective and well done, and the last lines round it out well. I'll have to seek out more of your work soon, and, if LiveJournal ever comes back up, rec this on the_new_library-- it doesn't have nearly enough reviews for its quality, even for a one-shot. Well Done indeed.

I love this fic, even though it is soo sad I nearly cried as I read it.

I want to give you 10/10 but I feel that even that is not good enough and that you deserve so much more.

I am off to read your other stories.

Wow. This was unexpectedly, tragically beautiful. And you killed Ron. Fantastic.

Wow. That's just beautiful. Thank you for this poignant story.

Oh God, that was so sad. My box of tissues were urgently required there. It takes a lot of skill to reduce people to tears. Hats off to you for your brilliant writing.

Simply beautiful. heartwrenchingly so. i love how you manage to use the title 'Good Enough' in the right spots to sum up the spirit of the moment, and the double viewpoint was excellently done.

O.o *dies*
you really should consider making writing your profession. This was absolutely wonderful!

Wow - that's heartbreakingly beautiful - thanks for the amazing story
Liz, UK

I love this fic! I think this is the second time I read it and I didn't even mean to. I must have forgotten at some point a while back to bookmark it and then I was reading your other Snape/Harry fics and found this in your profile. I really really love it. And I love all the other ones I've read, too. They're amazing. Keep writing!
~D*T*P~

this is beautifully written

great story. a real tear jerker.

wow pretty much brought me to tears its so simple yet so deep and sad great writing style and sso adding to my favs and c2 def gonna look at ur other fics now

This is such a lovely story. I loved the interaction between Snape and Harry. A sad story, but very beautiful.

Very sad, but very beautiful.

Wow. Very strong and well written