Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: Death is only the start of a new life
urges
2005-06-13 . chapter 1
Too bad he killed her in the end... There could have been so many other things he could have done.
I just wanted to correct you about something you said about Hitler.
You claimed he was half Jewish and that is not entirely acurate.
The facts are that Hitler's grandmother was a maid at a Jewish family's house while she was impregnanted with one of Hitler's parent (can't recall which). During those times it was quite common for the heads of families to have relations with their young maids and so it was believed that Hitler's grandmother's child was from her Jewish 'boss'. It was not proven though and just a speculation. If it was true then he would have been a quarter Jewish... The git.
Later on after coming to power Hitler came up with the Nirenberg rules, one of them who's porpuse was to keep the purity of the arien race states among others, that Christan women under the age of 45 cannot be maids to Jewish families, that was to make sure that they would not be impregnanted by their Jewish 'bosses' and have children that were half Jewish. Does that reming anyone of Hitler's grandmother's own life story? It does to me.
So I just wanted to correct you a bit about your facts of Hitler's heritage.

Thats all. Keep on writing.
Elizabeth A Shriver
2005-04-09 . chapter 1
wow im impressed especially with hermione but u didnt answer the question if ron died...neways it was like a really good story im not one for angst its just not me but i really liked this one alot
ickle-princess
2005-04-09 . chapter 1
Very good one shot,
its very sad tho :(
tho its very smart about what hermione said about hitler and everything else.
very good story tho :)
vry sad stpry as well :(.
from ickle-princess
xx
blonk
2005-04-09 . chapter 1
cool story!! love it, totally love it! and its really well writen!

from blonk
alias.of.me
2005-04-08 . chapter 1
going back on real history of Hitler was interesting. She has a point in what she says. and Voldemort actually considering Hermione's words the way this is laid out is going to be a really good story
Mitsuki Ashya
2005-04-08 . chapter 1
Wow. You are SUCH a good writer! I love this!

- Mitsuki Ashya
LadyErinSnape
2005-04-08 . chapter 1
A powerful one shot! I love that you captured Hermoine's spirit, even in the face of death she was a true Gryffindor.
BrennaM
2005-04-08 . chapter 1
Go Hermione! Way to tell the dark lord. I can totally picture her saying just that really. Really good story!
Return to Top