 Queen of the Skye 2009-07-14 . chapter 1oh...so...bloody...sad...crycrycry...how horrible...so sad i can't help but love it... |
 doidreamagain 2009-05-28 . chapter 1 beautiful in a tragic way that makes me want to cry... |
 finding 2009-04-08 . chapter 1Wow. Just... wow. |
 Princess of Pirates 2009-03-28 . chapter 1Wait so did she think raoul was Erik? I don't get it lol. Good story though. |
 KabutoLuvr 2008-10-07 . chapter 1Oh wow. Didn't see that coming. Well, kinda, when it was getting toward the end, but it didn't take away any of the impact. And even putting the twist ending aside it was extremely well written, I was especially impressed by the way you portrayed their interaction and Christine's emotions at the beginning. Well done. |
 the yellow flower 2007-12-28 . chapter 1what-thefreak-happened? omgoodness that was crazy! like-omgoodness i can't even like -whoa- ...i'm just going to stop trying to describe this... like whoa! |
 magicfingerrs 2007-12-26 . chapter 1AMAZING! Perfect, perfect, perfect!! This is amazing, you're an incredible writer! |
 Madame Leroux 2006-11-26 . chapter 1 OMG! CHRISTINE'S GONE CRACKERS!
Aw, poor Raoul. I'm sensing he needs a hug right now. *snuggles poor Vicomte* |
 Chibi Binasu-chan 2006-08-15 . chapter 1HAH!
I.. ... I saw that coming. AHEM. Yeah, I knew that would happen, totally! I mean. . . that was obvious. .(jk) . . HOLY CRAP, that was awesome! I have never read anything like it! It was actually rather sad, for Raoul that is. Poor fop... golly, that was awesome, I just keep re-reading it as I write this. . . . wowzers. I love this. I'm sorry, I just can't stop saying it. Well, I hope that you continue to write spooky stories like this one!
Have a cookie.
~Chibi |
 AngelicRose8 2006-07-14 . chapter 1I was NOT expecting that! Great job. I loved it |
 Phantress 2006-06-15 . chapter 1That you were shocked this one first place is just...alkdfjklaj, too humble, darling.
This is by far one of the most beautiful and poigant thing I have read on this site. It was obvious that everything was so meticulous and perfectly crafted. And, as for the story itself: so TRAGIC. I think TRAGIC and Phantom of the Opera go hand in hand, which is often ignored when it comes to fan fiction. However, you do not overlook that. The fact is, the story should not end happily in any aspect. Because...c'est la vie. Christine going mad by the end of it all is exactly correct...and hurray to you for showing that!
Also, your Raoul portrayl at the end there...just, bravo. Just bravo. Absolutely correct and canon.
You won for obvious reasons. |
 Karenina 2006-03-26 . chapter 1~~Dear Grasshopper,
what a wonderful piece of fiction! I was certainly not prepared for ~that~ ending, but I really liked it. I'll put it on my faves list! Great job.
~~Love~~,
Pushkin'sMuse |
 Rabidfangirl67 2005-12-02 . chapter 1Whoa this gave goosebumps, chilling, and very well written. |
 MadLizzy 2005-11-05 . chapter 1Very, very well done! Thank you for this great story! Congratulations on winning the morbid fiction contest. ~ML |
 PunjabHappyFriend 2005-08-16 . chapter 1OMG I was TOTALLY NOT prepared for THAT ending! ::blinks again:: Holy Crap!! I think I need to read this again... |