 Clio Ying 12/23/11 . chapter 1poor harry ... that's just soooo sad! im gonna cry! im gonna have nightmares about this... can you imagine hogwarts not exiting? |
 3dumplings3 12/16/11 . chapter 1gods, this is amazing. |
 liltle 8/19/11 . chapter 1An amazing turn to the HP-universe which reflected the possibility of a reality. Every description fitted so well that I couldn't help but compare this to 'Shutter Island'(I get it, I get it, its different, I know. But I get that same feeling there when I read this; the tragedy and emotion).
Anyway, love the twist and the characters that filled in here. Poor for them, but I was amazed with how well their positions lay in Harry's own 'world'. Having this take from Minerva's pov complements this story even more and the emotions she experienced. Overall, I'm happy that I stumbled into this which reminded me why I even bothered with FFN; the incredible things authors introduce to us which is sometimes beyond our own imaginary. Thanks for sharing. |
 Steve The Star 5/28/11 . chapter 1It sucks but that would be cool if that happened to me! I loved it! |
 Blazingstar of ThunderClan 2/11/11 . chapter 1Lol, I see this is supposed to be tragic, but I thought some parts were totally hilarious. Especially the part with Cho and her multiple personalities! :) |
 sexypancake 10/25/10 . chapter 1Wow. This fic is unbelievably strange and interesting. Nice interpretation of the books. It's fun to pic out familiar occurrences as they're happening in this fic. |
 BajaB 8/19/10 . chapter 1Interesting. |
 Natasha P 6/25/10 . chapter 1Your story made me laugh out loud on multiple occasions. I see that it was supposed to be tragic, but it really is hilarious. Great writing! |
 ZenJack 6/21/10 . chapter 1Wow. This is a pretty great spin on the world of Harry Potter. |
 Suzie1989 4/9/10 . chapter 1Very interesting idea, well done on incorporating a lot of the facts from the actual series. I love it.
Suzie |
 Anonymous is a pretty bad name 4/6/10 . chapter 1 Hahaha... Quite interesting. Nice retelling of this plot. |
 Dreamweaver Mirar 3/10/10 . chapter 1D:
Well done, but quite sad.
Keep up the good work. |
 KoiGirlPGSM 1/8/10 . chapter 1sad |
 wild wolf free17 12/29/09 . chapter 1... wow. This is awesome. |
 accallia 9/24/09 . chapter 1Nice. Very analytical, and it ties in wonderfully with the actual books. Impressive writing! |