Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: The Boy Who Lived: A Scientific Explanation - Page 1 of 2
Lydia Gormican
2003-08-16 . chapter 1
Interesting, although, as you most likely already know, it goes against canon. The prophesy says that EITHER Harry Potter OR Voldemort must die, and it must happen by the other's hand.
Despite this, good metaphysical expos on the cosmic connection between the boy wizard and the dark wizard. I'm trying to resist the urge to blab about this to my older brother, who has a Ph.D. in Mathematics, when I see him next week.
Inspired work!
Sam Davidson
2003-05-28 . chapter 1
You are a good author, with a very creative imagination and a pretty good tast in books, but I respectfully disagree. Potter will not die.
Daroga's Rainy Daae
2002-08-16 . chapter 1
ok, I'm lost. Is this supposed to be serious? *checks the genre* Poetry, eh? Doesn't sound much like poetry, but... yeah.

And is all this supposed to be true? Or are you just making it up? It's hard to tell, you write it convincingly. This may confuse ppl... like me...

But surprisingly, the actual story doesn't confuse me. question: does the same True Name of 2 people apply to twins, or not?

For example: Two twin men married twin sisters, and both lived in the same house and died within a day of each other. Would that count as having the same True Name? How do you find out your true name?

Nice figuring anyway, now just try to tell this to JK Rowling. In my opinion, her story isn't as deep as what you're explaining to us in this, and I believe Voldemort will die and Harry will live. (It's just a fantasy story after all, and I don't think JK is writing towards what you're saying in this theory-thingy here - I know she puts a lot of thought into the HP books, but not THAT much. Besides, the books are written for children, and I doubt most of them could understand this True Name thingy.)

Ah well, this was really interesting anyway. :)
Malleana
2002-04-18 . chapter 1
Cool. You really are a genius! wow, and i thought I was smart for skipping a grade.....
gyr falre
2002-03-04 . chapter 1
It is impossible that Harry Potter and the Dark Lord Voldemort share the same true name due to the simple fact of age. were they to live a similar life, that would imply that harry would also have a clan of devoted followers who follow his every whim. tell me, is that depicted in JK's books, or am I missing something.
Love always,
--Gyr
muralsa
2001-05-21 . chapter 1
I liked it, but you should write it in English, so us peasasnts can understand it.
Technomad
2001-04-15 . chapter 1
An interesting idea, explaining HP's survival, within the bounds of the Potterverse. Ingenious.
TheDevilChild
2001-04-03 . chapter 1
Aaah yes, yet another person explaining the death of our favorite hero. Do tell me something though, how can you be sure that Rowling knows of this theory? I have a hunch that she does, she would be the very person I would think to think something like this up.... Anyway, very interesting, must ponder this a bit, oh and did I mention, you are brilliant?
dsfd
2001-04-01 . chapter 1
if you're serious about the mageologist bit than you're are crazy
Abby
2001-03-31 . chapter 1
Okay. That...was strange.
allie
2001-03-30 . chapter 1
interesting and i do agree
Lunamew
2001-03-30 . chapter 1
You lost me there.
Lorelei
2001-03-30 . chapter 1
I UNDERSTOOD IT!!!! DUDE!!! LoL. OMG, I HAVE to get this book, man . . . I loved it! But just one question; what do you suppose Harry's and Voldemort's names are?
MPS
2001-03-30 . chapter 1
Interesting
Crazy Michael
2001-03-30 . chapter 1
Yes, I truly agree.
I think the "offspring" put it best in the booklet for the "consiracy of one" album
"Two men from opposite sides,
bound together by a siamese ripcord
tethered to their souls."
"Who will pull first, Knowing that it will destroy them both?"
Return to Top