 ben 3/21/07 . chapter 9 nice the whole story was awesome |
 Darth Hawk 32 1/31/05 . chapter 9Not bad, I liked it, especially the way you got all the couples, that most everyone agrees should be together, together in a decently realistic way. This one would make a good manga. |
 dennisud 11/28/03 . chapter 9Wow talk about histting all the genres in one story. From Waff to dark, from comedy to drama, from Romance to hatred. All in one neat package. Excellent use of an ACC(Nayami) and even though you kept the accepted pairings, you made them come together logically and believably!
Nicely done!
dennisud |
 dogbertcarroll 11/11/03 . chapter 9Excellent ending. Outstanding! |
 dogbertcarroll 11/11/03 . chapter 8LOL! Kuno was fantastic!
Great ending. I disapprove of the
typical pairings. They just don't
work for me, but I have to say you
did a great job. I liked it! |
 dogbertcarroll 11/11/03 . chapter 7Dr. Tofu comes across as a bit of a scumbag. |
 dogbertcarroll 11/11/03 . chapter 6The plot thickens. So she was having her own daughter tortured? |
 dogbertcarroll 11/11/03 . chapter 5"Yes, you is too too nonexistent in the chest region!"
*chuckle*
Good explanation for why Akane is spending so much time
trying to get Ryoga and Ukyou together and not thinking
of Ranma.
Dark ending. |
 dogbertcarroll 11/11/03 . chapter 4You are working on pairing up Ukyou and Ryoga
much too quickly. It you wanted it to be
believable you would have to have tossed in a
couple of flashbacks and some interior
monologues for a month or two beforehand.
When did Akane become so concerned with playing
matchmaker that she forgot Ranma completely?
Kuno as usual has played his part perfectly!
*grin* |
 dogbertcarroll 11/11/03 . chapter 3"that looked like the unholy union of a cooking utensil and a blade"
*snicker*
Since when is Akane as talented as the other fiancés? |
 dogbertcarroll 11/11/03 . chapter 2Akane sure causes a lot of his problems. He
was planning a trip by himself and she has
to involve all the people he was avoiding.
The interaction between Ryoga and Ukyou seems
off somehow.
So where did Ryoga's clothes go? They should
still have been on the roof where Ukyou could
easily have seen them.
We need a reason for Nabiki to be up in the
middle of the night for her discovering of
Ryoga's secret to be believable. |
 dogbertcarroll 11/11/03 . chapter 1Good start. A little too Akane-centric for my tastes,
but then that's just personal preference. You have
a nice clear writing style that's easy to read. |
 may 6/4/01 . chapter 9 Truly magnificent story! A wonderful ending! |
 may 5/28/01 . chapter 7 A truly amazing story! Each chapter is quite an adventure! This has been a very emotional chapter with the way you ended it! I am excited to read the next chapter! |
 Neohowler 4/9/01 . chapter 5 this is getting cool. So whats the big secret of the mountain? |