 Purdy 2009-10-31 . chapter 10To quote you, you requested, "I appreciate any comments, the more robust the better." I looked up the word "robust" and it has quite a few definitons from healthy, to bold, to rough, to rude. Well, to make this absolutely clear, I certainly do NOT ever want to be rude, especially to a veteran 1xR writer who I admire greatly. But for the longest while now, I have refrained myself from writing a review to avoid just that. Being rude to you. Everyone else is absolutely over the clouds in love with this story, and very understandably so. However, this has made me very frustrated b/c I seem to be the lone wolf, the black sheep when it comes to how I feel towards the story...
I can't possibly hate the story. Otherwise, why would I keep coming back? Just the pure intensity and the drama you've created b/t Heero and Relena is what we 1xR fans crave. And I would be a blatant liar if I said I have never come back to this story just to read the lemons alone, b/c I have. Many a time;) And the writing itself, is something so mature and so out of the ordinary good of the fanfiction world, its like finding a gem among the rough.
However, though I can't say I hate the story, I do not like it as well. In fact, what you have done, what you have written has absolutely infuriated me to my wits end I do not understand why nobody else has said anything about it. And these feelings are caused, specifically by Relena. I am so sorry, but I cannot stand her in this story. How can I possibly feel sorry for her? Am I suppose to? Am I suppose to feel sad for her and wish for a happy ending? Seriously, how? Is that what you wanted the readers to feel? B/c I'm just so confused on how I can feel that for her...and even more confused that your readers are actually feeling it!@_@
I have commented once on live journal, and I'll come clean and apologize in advance about it. I wasnt exactly cordial. I'm sorry. However, it wasn't really directed towards you, but mainly towards RElena. Of course you wrote RElena this way in the story, so yes indirectly it was towards you. Again, I am sorry. To paraphrase, I said something along the lines of how Relena had lost all her marbles from all the banging she did with Heero. Again, I am really really sorry.O_O And again, I am not writing this to start a war with you, or to be mean. Actually, I'm writing this to maybe learn from you, and most of all to understand you. Andn to understandn Relena in this story. Seriously what was she thinking? I know that in love stories like this the characters, more often than not, the female, are suppose to lose themselves in the lust, love and obessesion of it all. I mean, isn’t that the whole point of indulging in these stories? To feel the slightly semblance of what it is to be in love, especially for those of us, like me, who have never felt that emotion before? But Relena in this story….you have made me loathe her more and more with each chapter that has passed. How in the beginning, she was simply fine—more than fine: she was 24, playful, full of life and humor. Then yes, she slipped fell back in love with Heero and lost herself—all understandable—but slowly but so surely, she becomes this almost co-dependant love sick, (really sick sick) dog that just can’t live without him. This young, strong woman who was once Queen of the World, survived a war, and one of the most benevolent and most intelligent female characters I love and admire was being destroyed by a love story. You really made my heart ache, Zapenstap.
As a fellow Relena fan to another, you must have gone through the same motions that I have. How in the beginning you were swept away with the story of RElena and Heero, and the bountiful possibilities that sparked your imagination. And how you eventually loved them separately as well, especially Relena, this smart, bright young girl….and how the second you learned there were all these malicious haters towards someone that stood for peace, your mind kicked into overload in defending her—of course in the most mature and dignified manner as possibly, b/c that how RElena would’ve wanted it. How you would just simply ignore or easily debunk the arguments that she was nothing more than a delusional, useless, clingy, co-dependant, rich spoiled damsel in distress. And yet when I read the RElena you have portrayed in this fic, it feels like a slap in the face to everything RElena is and what we fans have defended of her. It feels like a betrayal.
But yikes, I’ve already lost my mind here. Let me try to regroup. Its not to say that I want Relena to be perfect. Of course not! It would be even worse, if not devastatingly BORING if all our interpretations of Relena was her being nothing more than the always good, always moral, always pure princess of peace. We read stories to learn the flaws of our favourite characters. It’s the flaws that make them interesting. The mistakes create a story. Its just I simply think you went OVERBOARD with the flaws. You’re not even overboard the ship, you’re in a completely different dimension-you’re in bizarreville. Relena isn’t RElena anymore—she’s this worn out shell and a crazy woman has possessed her. How she just keeps going back to him and taking all that crap. I don’t blame her for not being unable to fall out of love with him, but I blame her for putting herself in the situation that she still can’t lead a happy full life without him. I mean, I know she continues on living her life and all but it still certainly feels like that. And what, is Heero the only emotionally steadfast in her life?o.O What, she doesn’t have other friends to fall back on? Other than that out of her mind Candace Mae? Seriously, other than work, her life revolves around Heero, that one man? Please correct me if I’m wrong, but I don’t’ remember a single mention of anyone else in her life. No girlfriends, no Zechs…its all Heero Heero Heero.
Please help me understand. I want to like her I do, but I just can’t. Help me. Am I suppose to like her after how she’s behaved? After her choices? Of her keeping the baby, and tricking (or trying to trick) a perfectly decent, good man into believing that that was his baby. And now all of a sudden, everything is falling apart-WHAT DID SHE THINK WAS GOING TO HAPPEN?!o.O I mean, I know that the only other option was to get an abortion, and I’m not even going to go into detail on that one with a 20 foot pole. But she didn’t even stop just a moment and think on how that choice would’ve saved everyone from a spiralling whirlpool of pain, lies, and heartache? How it would save her life from turning into, what she says herself is a “spectacle”?
Which then brings me to the very end of my insane obsession with this story….I can’t see a happy ending. I really don’t. In fact, I don’t’ think Relena or Heero deserve a happy ending. Heero’s screwed up too many times and as for Relena…..she’s made her bed(no pun intended) and she should LIE in it. And that is how I feel. That is the very power of your writing Zapenstap. Its driven my inner geek insane! LOL. And I need your help to get out of it. And I need you to know that I have written this review with much thought and all the decorum I have inspite of my feelings towards this story. If you can’t tell, I even tried a bit of humour. But please please, I really hope you don’t take this as an attack. I have admired your skill as a writer for years. I would even love it if you were to become my mentor to help me get out of my writing hiatus….and if I may say so, even become friends. So I hope to hear back from you.
And of course, I will be waiting with baited, impatient breath for the final chapter. Your faithful reader, Purdy |