Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: Winterstar - Page 1 of 38
Wolfy Pup
2009-10-10 . chapter 47
*Sniff* I am in tears right now. Awesome story but very depressing ending.
venom'in'her'veins
2009-08-12 . chapter 35
I thought chapter 33 was sad. holy crap.
"And then sirius's world stopped, because James Potter lay dead at his feet"
reduced me to a blubbering idiot for at least 15 minutes. why'd JK have to kill them?!?!? :'( :'(
it doesn't help that We Are Broken by Paramore started playing, either. top quality, but extremely depressing, work. good job, i suppose :'( :'(
venom'in'her'veins
2009-08-12 . chapter 33
Oh my god. This chapter has made me cry so hard. I both hate you and love you for writing something so amazing. Oh my god, I'm gonna be sobbing so hard I'm going to dehydrate myself :'( <--does not convey the way I'm feeling...*insert sad laughter here*
dancelikeyoujustdontcare
2009-02-27 . chapter 18
okay I'm just going to stop reading now because i know your going to go on and tell how their friendship splits up and i hate being reminded of that! I love the story so far though
tresdrole
2008-08-05 . chapter 38
I dunno if her rationalization over why going to Dumbledore would be a terrible idea makes sense, but I suppose you have to keep it canon :P
tresdrole
2008-08-05 . chapter 35
AH SO SAD! This story got very very awesome once they left school. I LOVE it now. Not even the Sabrina bits; I just ADORE how you portray the marauders. Reading this chapter made me nearly cry. If I'd been playing sad music, I WOULD have cried! Jeez, girl!

*favs* :)
tresdrole
2008-08-05 . chapter 34
Brilliant. This story just gets better and better!
tresdrole
2008-08-05 . chapter 33
Why are they saying goodbye forever? They would still be able to visit so long as Peter told them the location...
tresdrole
2008-08-05 . chapter 32
This part is getting very interesting! You make the decision to switch to Wormtail make lots of sense :) Well done!
tresdrole
2008-08-05 . chapter 14
aww how sweet! I'm enjoying this story! It continues to be well-written and your characterizations are good :)
tresdrole
2008-08-05 . chapter 1
Well, it's well-written. I'm pretty sure I know exactly how the plot will go from here on out... but most fanfiction is that way, so no worries! And I look forward to seeing if these OCs are well-developed characters... will Katie be a vapid **? Will Sabrina be perfect in every way imaginable?
On to chapter two! :)
Bip-Bop-Boop
2008-07-01 . chapter 37
oh. my. god. i never once cried during the books. i felt hollow, depressed, i got choked up, i punched the pages, i got big waves of depression, but never ONCE cried. this fan fiction actually made me cry.
Bip-Bop-Boop
2008-07-01 . chapter 32
I've been reading this like mad, determined to finish before it gets too late and I simply fall asleep. I'm literally freaking out here... even though I know what happens in the end, it's just as suspensful.
Bip-Bop-Boop
2008-07-01 . chapter 31
this is the second night ive spent staying up late reading this story. it is AMAZING. Normally in marauders fics I get bits of sadness that they die, but in this I get serious waves of it, and I almost don't want to read anymore because of their impending doom. You're doing an AWESOME job. I can't wait to finish!!
midnightsun3721
2008-05-18 . chapter 47
Oh my gosh, that had to be one of THE BEST! fanfics i have ever read! :)
It was extremely well written and had a good plot line!
I was SO upset when James and Lily died, I almost started crying! :'(
I'm really sorry for not reviewing before now, but i was trying to read as fast as possible, I'm not really supposed to be on the computer :)

But, yeah, I TOTTALY LOVED IT!
:) :):):):):):)
Return to Top