Oh, poor Erik! Poor CHRISTINE! I sobbed like a baby! Quick question: Which version is this based off of?

Sad but very sweet

Kindest Regards

ER

I love this story. i wish you would continue it past a oneshot.

Many Phantom of the Opera fics have made me sad but this was the first one that actually made me cry. It was so sad yet I could not stop reading, I simply love it.

Oh my gosh... this was so cruel to read, yet I couldn't tear my eyes away! Poor Erik; he must have difficulty keeping himself together. :( Fantastic, brillant job!

*cries* Por Erik!

*cries*

Wonderful! You capture the moment and the Characters beautifully!

Now i need a happy phic...

But beautiful job!

That was so sad.

I'm about to cry.

I am crying so bad right now-I'm practically weeping...

that was intense, no wonder it won an award. that was incredible. wow, that is all i can say

Aw... *tear*

*sob* That was beautiful!

aw how sweet! i loved it!

I'm seriously crying! The story is beautiful!