Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Search
Reviews for: Bright and Sunny
anon 8/22/11 . chapter 1
Ahhh, the "noble" suicide. The coward's way out...

Yet the reasoning and emotional buildup seems sound and understandable and of course the ambience you've constructed is fittingly creepy and perverted.

All in all a nice little play with a neat little idea, but not truly anything i could see the "seven books alongside us" Harry do. Waiting for an AK without blinking? Yes. Slitting his wrists and bleed out like a butchered animal? Naaaa.
Caaro 11/8/10 . chapter 1
This was so good. So simple, and still telling so much. Really liked it!
fishertowers 9/14/10 . chapter 1
Wow. Eerie. I think I almost prefer this ending to the one in the book. Almost. But this was very well written. Not one complaint. You are an excellent writer.

FT
Jemma Blackwell 8/24/07 . chapter 1
It's so interesting that you wrote this so long before book 7 came out. You had it right! without the knife and blood of course, but the sacrifice was spot on. How cool is that?
madbrad 12/1/06 . chapter 1
Well, this plot didn't make too much sense to me. First off, the prophecy doesn't imply that the death of one mandates the death of the other, at all, to my mind. I couldn't see how Harry could have arrived at that conclusion.

(The reverse, though, is interesting ... as long as both are alive, theoretically they are immortal, invulnerable to everything except each other. As you/Harry noted, "no one would be able to stop us".)

Secondly, if one's dying could kill the other, why should Harry be so melodramatic and prance out to reach Voldemort? Just kill himself in his dormitory ... say goodbye to all of his friends, etc.

What would be a chilling story would be a departure from this ... 'awareness lit Voldemort's eyes, he stupefied me, then imprisoned me forever, keeping me just barely alive'?
emilina potter 6/1/06 . chapter 1
Don't mind my language, but fuck that was good. Seriously, i have goosebumps. Like shit man. I loved the ending line, and the self-sacrifice idea was amazing. And the title is perfect. Keep up the good work!
Ambergold Wolfeyes 7/23/05 . chapter 1
This raised goosebumps all over. And all too plausible.

Damn. Now I'm going to have to scrub my brain out so

I can finish reading book 6.
JaneAlpha 7/4/05 . chapter 1
excellent!

luv katie
Serenity Meowth 7/4/05 . chapter 1
The word count is creepy...

I was wondering why he had just a knife, until the end, of course. _
Return to Top