Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: As Simple as That - Page 1 of 2
Kyoshi7989
2008-02-22 . chapter 1
oh, I like it very much. I have to admit that I really enjoy this pairing, but never thought it could really be made plausible...but you made it work.
The Captain
2007-05-02 . chapter 1
Ah! Typos!

Just kidding (about freaking out, not the typos). Mayumi-chan, this is a good story. It is so... minimalist. I understand everything without feeling overloaded.

You are a very. good. writer.

::scampers off to read more::
queenofthedonuts
2007-01-25 . chapter 1
"A/N: I don't know how I feel about this story. I mean, a RoyxWinry w/o angst? Is that even possible?"

apparently so
Decce
2007-01-24 . chapter 1
I love this pairing!! You did a really good job and it's convincing, even though there's no angst.

I like how everything was easy to read and their relationship was casual but believable. Awesome job ;)

- decce
Paris Lee
2006-09-27 . chapter 1
This is very cute...I love it...More Roy and Winry please? Please? Please? Thank you!
Jasmine Dawn Pendragon
2006-05-09 . chapter 1
I like it actually. Its not that they have feelings for each other suddenly, its over time and its exactly how I could imagine it, just with a little more details.
MastahChibeh
2006-01-28 . chapter 1
That was very good! I have always loved this pairing but I can never write it. You are talented, so keep up the good work! I shall fave and c2 this!

-Chibeh-
Genkai-chan
2006-01-22 . chapter 1
I liked it. ^^
evilredmenace
2005-12-16 . chapter 1
I guess this is review day for Miss Camudekyu.

The things I like: the simplicity of the dialogue, the kind of thoughtless banter leading up to easy conversation. I can actually see the two of them bonding as sort of a catharsis of tension and trauma.

Things I'm questioning: Winry as a coffee girl? What happened to the automail asskicker? I suppose if something was needed to bring the two of them together, coffee is as good as anything. And you're right... a realistic Roy + Winry scenario would sort of necessitate some angst at an exponential level.

But I enjoyed it. And I was sort of playing through the possible implications contrasting this piece with "The Alchemologist." I like to imagine that Ed would hemmorage if he knew that the two of them shared a moment. Or a series of moments. Nekkid moments. :)
liliwick the WORD
2005-12-04 . chapter 1
I feel oddly light-hearted after reading this. Your story is simple and short - yet it's just nice in its own way. I love it! =3
Kesiah
2005-10-11 . chapter 1
I actually quite liked this, which is a tad odd as I've never really considered this pairing before (though I can see where the angst would step in).
I like the way you wrote this, the shortness works much better than the blow-by-blow descriptions of emotions that we tend to get in fluff and romance fanfics. It lets the reader decide the emotions themselves, in a way. We can see that Winry is a little confused about her feelings for Roy, but you can show that without having her wangst on and on about if she likes him or not.
Bonus points to you!
naru-san
2005-10-10 . chapter 1
I love the simple fact that you wrote a winryxroy
fanfic.But it lack's emotion, and it has way to many
fine details in it.Think of it this way, your winry
what manner of a slow prosses would you take when
a cute guy ask you out?
Why not take it slow,not just by writting,
he came to the coffee shop one day,and in between that
you put to little detail of what there filling,to the reader love is a fast prosses becaues to them thay only think of whats gonna happen next?
Show the reader a slow passionate love,that in that very second the reader has now become the charator.
remember take it slow,a kind word of evies,from a friend.
Eleventy Nine
2005-08-11 . chapter 1
I wouldn't have thought it possible, either.

Hey, you made it work, though. Impressive, really.
Gina
2005-08-11 . chapter 1
Apparently, yes.
Infinitesimi
2005-08-08 . chapter 1
wha... winry and roy? i dont think ive ever read that pairing before, so i cant really say i have anything to compare it to... but it is quite angst free, which strikes me as odd. this fic is really very subtle. i like that its mostly conversation. for some reason that is what makes it most believable.
Return to Top