 Ariel 2009-10-20 . chapter 1 Aww poor Snape. I luv the end with the reference to Dumbledore! Great job! |
 May Eve 2008-11-08 . chapter 1Brilliant. ^^ |
 PhoenixOfSilver 2008-06-15 . chapter 1Very nice story, and very in-character. Especially loved the Dumbledore reference in 'white bumblebee'. |
 elsa2 2008-05-11 . chapter 1 lovely dialogue |
 SylvanDreamer 2008-01-31 . chapter 1This was lovely. I adore fics with great wordplay. And I love the relationship Harry and Snape have here. It's not really very angsty but that's also another thing I love about it. Great job. |
 Tooi ake 2007-07-22 . chapter 1Excellent story. |
 seekerchick06 2007-07-15 . chapter 1Didn't get the last line but i loved it! |
 Iva1201 2006-07-09 . chapter 1Oh my - this is perfect. I like how you have pictured them all - especially Snape. Thank you for such a wonderful one-shot. (-: |
 VickiWeasley 2006-07-03 . chapter 1I REALLY LIKED THIS IT FLOWED VERY WELL |
 Sinful Wolf and Adena McGee 2006-06-25 . chapter 1It is great to see how Severus is so calm, something we do not get to see in the fic. He has at this point attained peace.
Funny how he still tries to "teach" Harry, making him think for himself instead of revealing the whole thing which could have been easier.
- Adena McGee |
 lanenkar 2006-06-13 . chapter 1 A very well thought out short story. Most enjoyable. Really enjoyable! Good writing all 'round. |
 elenyil 2006-05-16 . chapter 1 Nicely done.
You have managed to capture the subtlety, the complexity inherent in such a relationship in so little words. I have always advocated that the anecdote is a far better indicator of craftsmanship than the dredging novel.
Your allusions are again, subtle and complex. Well thought out. Your last line is compelling for whomever takes the time to sit and think.
Nicely done. |
 Ija Ijevna 2006-05-16 . chapter 1Oh, dear.
Just see what you've done: You made me stop reading, find my "Complete Works of William Shakespeare", and then you caused a non-native English speaker to struggle (with pleasure!) through Elisabethan Ye Olde English. ;-) Then the awed non-native English speaker returned to your fic, squeaking "Pindarus! Oh my God, Pindarus! Did Rowling also have it in her mind?!" That's what you can call author's full success. ;->
Ekhm. Seriously - it's a really good story (I'm referring to yours, not to Shakespeare's ;), with believable Snape (a rarity), not-irritating Harry and well directed dialogues. What can I say more?
Maybe: write more; you've found an eager reader.
Ija |
 breannatala 2006-04-26 . chapter 1Nice. I really like it. |
 Tyleet27 2006-03-29 . chapter 1Ohh...so good...I *really* like this...Will you please continue it? This is too good a story to be so short...although I am just being greedy, I suppose...and I can never bear to leave my darlings in tragic situations. Please? For Sev? And...well...I got a hint of Severitis in the story, but have you ever considered slash? |