|Reviews for The Half Blood Prince|
| sevvii 10/14/11 . chapter 8
MORE MORE MORE. LOVE IT.
| YuriyTalaIvanov 3/13/09 . chapter 8
omg! update this! you have to! i love it! you cant just leave it at this horrible horrible cliffie!
| JustDeadStarsForDeadEyes 8/30/07 . chapter 8
another great fic cant wait for more
| mioneweasley-witch 8/16/07 . chapter 8
Oh please update! I know it's been awhile but please come back to this story! :D Will Severus and Lilly ever talk again? Your story is very good!
* mioneweasley_witch *
| excessivelyperky 10/1/06 . chapter 8
Dun dun DUN! Up cues the Evil Music-and of course this meeting was planned to take place exactly like this. Tommy Boy used to have brains on before the whole Unfortunate Incident in Godric's Hollow.
| Carol J 10/1/06 . chapter 8
I just found you're story and now I'm waiting for tomorrow. Good story!
| Kitala 9/30/06 . chapter 8
Ooh! *Squees and patiently awaits the next chappie*
| Sara Morgan Black 9/30/06 . chapter 8
Just for a few weeks I thought you had forgotten the story. Thanks God I were wrong!
I liked the chapter and will be waiting the next one!
| Iva1201 8/7/06 . chapter 1
Oh dear, this is an excellent piece of writing - do you think you will be able to go on - SOON? It's worth it! Unlike many authors you have also Lucius older than Severus what he indeed is and you wrote quite a nice piece of conversation between the headmaster and young Snape - please, go on! At least until Severus turned spy. PLEASE! I would love to read your opinion to the topic! (-:
| Nyu 7/25/06 . chapter 6
Hello I'm from Mexico and I have started reading your fic in spanish but I love it that much that i decided to look for it in English, I hope you will continue your fic soon, I'll be waiting. Snape is one of my favorite characters and I always wanted to know more about his childhood, thanks for make it possible
P.D:Sorry about grammar I'm not good at english
| Kitala 4/7/06 . chapter 7
Ooh *squee* So tense! *Loves it* Evil, evil cliffie.
| Nadreth 3/29/06 . chapter 7
I love your writing style - it fits with what J.K. writes and yet at the same time is very unique - Also I think you are capturing Severus's character better with every single chapter - I cannot wait for the next chapter.
| venus pudica 3/28/06 . chapter 7
awesome! keep it up, i love your story so much!
| Aragon 3/28/06 . chapter 4
How magnanimous of Dumbledore to apologize for condoning and excusing the bullying and allowing Lupin to abuse his prefect-status! Especially since he doesn't even mean it and feels he did nothing wrong, negating any value the gesture might have had otherwise. And really, it was just a little murder-attempt, how dare Severus to feel outraged - boys will be boys, eh? And while we're all equals here the Griffindors are just a bit more equal... If this was his attitude in canon too (and it seems so from the books) it's no wonder that a disgusted teenage Severus was feeling betrayed and choose the other alternative.
Bellatrix is (weirdly, since I too thought it would be Andromeda with daughter Tonks already being around 22 during OotP) the oldest of the sisters and she was a 7th year when Severus started Hogwarts! So by now she'd probably already be married to Rodolphus for some years and kneedeep into Voldemort-worship... And Andromeda also must have left school already for some time - otherwise there's no way Tonks could have finished school and three years of Auror-training in OotP.
Not sure about Tonks sen being an animagus but since it's not impossible from canon-info go for it. It would be a novel to see Tonks metamorphmagus-ability coming from the male muggleborn side of the family instead of the Blacks.
I also find the notion the animagi are truly rare laughable. I know McGonagall said something like this but she refered to the fact that "there were only 7 REGISTERED animagi in one century". If the ability is really rare there's no way that 3 out of 3 (!) students (PPW) could have achieved it - and without guidance too. The statistical possibility goes beyond 1 to a few millions. We too have Rita Skeeter and of the 5 known Animagi in canon 4 are NOT registered: meaning that it's probably rare for wizards to register themselves with the Ministry which I think realistic seeing what an excentric, individualistic and not very lawabiding bunch wizardkind is. And there might be several wizards who managed the transformation only to find their animal-form totally useless for their purposes (like finding out you're a blind deepsea fish able to exist only 600m under water _) and thus not using it later, regarding it as a waste...
| Possum132 3/27/06 . chapter 7
I can see Lucius courting the brilliant young nobody in just this way ... and Voldemort was just an ambitious and ruthless politician at this stage in the game.