The summary sounded very interesting. I'll keep reading it though.

Oh my goodness, this is hysterical. Varda causing supernovae! Tulkas and Nessa taking over Mandos! The Fëanorians' escape attempts! I also like your portraits of three different fanficcer stereotypes: the Suethor, the fanatical purist, and the hobbit fangirl. (Not to mention the mad Potterite -- good grief!)

Also, the title is perfect. ; ) It doesn't look as if there's much chance of your coming back to finish this, but just in case you were considering it, know that you will have at least one avid reader.

I have been scrounging around for ages for something DECENT that I haven't read, and then I notice this odd story on one of my favorite author's account. 'Weird,' I thought. 'I haven't seen that yet.' Then I wondered some more if this would be a good read or not.

But you have astounded me once again with one of your hilarious stories. C'est parfait, mon ami!

Parody isn't usually my thing and usually gets dull after the first 10 chapters, but I really like this story. Any chance of this story getting finished?

You just have to continue this. I began to read it at school and since the day you uploaded the last chapter I waited for the next. I don't love most parodies much, but yours made me laugh so often. And I want to know how it ends with them all! You can't let us leave without an ending!

:( I'd very much like to read the rest of the story.

I think I've fallen in love with it... ;)

Now, this I like. No more Sauron Is A Suit Of Armor With No Personality.

Besides, I actually think you accidently) hit on a valid philosophical point. Evil really is only immaturity on a vast level. "I want toys," becomes "I want countries." "I want friends who do what I say," becomes "I want minions who do what I say."

Sauron acts immature because he is evil; all evil is immature.

Well done, and an enjoyable fic.

Excellent! I've read all the way here now and needless to say, I would love to see the conclusion of this story, epic within its own right.

Mandos as the new Dark Lord, primary antagonist of Arda is certainly a creative concept and does appeal to me.

Warm regards,
Mandos 117

Comic and creative! The considerable amount of time I've devoted to reading what is approximately the first half of this work has certainly not been wasted!

I look forward to finishing the second half.

Warm regards,
Mandos 117

Erestor,

I completely agree with Earendilion. You have to update! I have been reading your story for close to a year and it is one of the best. PLEASE UPDATE! Just put up something! If this is a test of the loyalty of your fans, then all of us have passed with flying colors. We will all go into the west and remain Erestor fans.

Please update!
Frodo

A fanfiction that makes fun of fanfictions and is actually funny! And it's quite lengthy too, but the problem with really good fics is that they are never quite as long the reader would like them to be...

I find myself liking Sauron (a person who likes spiders can't be all that bad, right?)

It's a good story, but update the goddamned thing!

It's a good story, but
update the goddamned thing!

Wow. You. Are. Incredible. That's all I have to say, lol. That, and please do finish this eventually! :D

Erestor, I am on my knees. If I could go any lower, I would. PleasepleasepleasepleasePLEASE update. Your story is wonderful. I know everyone else has said it, but it really is the best parody I've ever read. PLEASE finish it! Especially now that Mandos has the Ring... cheers for DOOM&GLOOM. Again, I love your story, it's brilliant, I laugh every time I read and re-read it. Please update!

An adoring fan,
Earendilion