 Delrusant 2009-11-08 . chapter 3dialogue between harry and his daughter are too formal for a monoparental family, there is not really any warmth in them. |
 MaeSilverpaws1 2009-07-05 . chapter 18I liked this one... i would like to read more about Sam and her schooling and if harry allows himself to be happy and loved again... Mae |
 WhiteElfElder 2009-06-05 . chapter 18This as a fun story. Kinda surprised that you didn't have something from Ginny or another interested try to sway Harry's attention...though I doubt it could have been swayed...he was rather single-minded for one female. |
 lensman 2009-04-21 . chapter 18Great story. Thanks for the great read.
Your Harry is one you don't want to make mad.
Thanks again |
 ElfGuard48 2009-03-16 . chapter 18Wonderful story. I love the new Harry. Dumbles got the dressing down he needed. I like Samantha also. Harry would teach his kids the things he learned the hard away. Thank you for a wonderful story. masterfully written. Kept me on the edge of my seat. |
 tar heels superstar 2009-03-09 . chapter 18great story and was glad to read it so keep writing and i can't wait to read more. |
 Queen of Ravenclaw 2008-11-06 . chapter 18this is so moving. its what should have happened from the begining and i applod you for writing it out. i love how dumbles wasn't evil lie in some fics but just had his flaws. Your harry is one of the best i've seen you combined the love of a father with the braveness of a gryffindor.
keep writing
lexy |
 q.thews 2008-10-12 . chapter 9While i'm liking what i'm reading something isn't right:
Why she didn' get any concealment charms ? A new transfer student, black hair, green eyes, great quidditch player, good at DADA come to Hogwarts the same school year as Professor Potter, ok, she has a different name but...
Nothing "big" happened yet (but the last couple lines of this chapter may hit that something is going to happen)
Ciao! |
 keichan2 2008-05-31 . chapter 18It was quite a good story, here... With a good finish, the only way it could end.
I think that given how Sam was worried about her father, her saving him from Dominic was a good thing for her. I also iked the symbolism of Sam ending Voldemort, instead of Harry. |
 SomeGuyFawkes 2008-05-21 . chapter 4Not terrible but not particularly engaging either. Abandoning for now. |
 SomeGuyFawkes 2008-05-20 . chapter 1Promising. Somewhat awkward grammar. |
 HayliexXxMalfoy 2008-03-27 . chapter 18 aww you need to make a little one-shot sequal :) telling about what house they go into and how they all recover :) great story by the way :) |
 Sam 2008-03-07 . chapter 18 Great Story |
 graup-hagrid 2008-02-10 . chapter 18I enjoyed the story - you captured what Harry should have been doing all along - taking the offensive.
DD is mad with the love and "turning them back to the light". Well, I preferred your way of handling it.
Thanks for sharing the story. |
 shadowryder 2007-09-03 . chapter 2I've enjoyed this so far, but I do have one thing that I want to say - in your dialogue they're always saying stuff like "I have" and "I am" and "It is" when in real life, people are a lot more likely to say I've, I'm, It's, etc. then the two words. I can see Dumbledore saying I am and such, but for a kid like Samantha and for Ron, I can't imagine them talking like that. |