please update! I love this story! It's awesome!

yeh that was a sad chapter, please update soon

le gasp! she disobeyed erik dun dun dun! man Joshua is becoming more like his father every day

HURRAY! I'VE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS STORY! REALLY GREAT SO FAR. UPDATE SOON. AND IF YOU COULD, CHECK OUT MY PHANTOM STORY "YOU DON'T HAVE TO BE A HERO". YOU MIGHT LIKE IT. IT INCLUDES THE SONG FROM BALTO 3.

Oh come on I read through 51 chapters and skimmed the first 21 of the last story refreshing my memory and u do this...More soon I command it

Wowness. I actually started crying with Christine. That was a very good way to give Joshua the deformity. I like that, a lot. Bravissima~!

YEAH! Mme. Giry is back. Poor Joshua I hope he's okay. Well done and it's good to hear from you again. Well, I gotta go practice for my musical guys and dolls. Can't wait until the next chapter! You know we all love you!

Oh no! Surely Christine won't go to Hell for saving her son. It was a good deed! It can't happen! I'm sure Erik won't stand for it. I love this! Update soon please!

Hey!
Great chapter!
One thing though...I really wanna know when Erik and Lotte will interact! Please update soon!8-)

Yay! More Erik! =) Though he's gonna be SO mad when Christine tells him...I doubt being dead made his temper diminish.

Please continue as fast as possible?

Ugh...I hate it when school and stuff gets in your way...
Speaking of school, i need to do my homework!

But I'm glad I read this instead.

Great story!

Oh this is soo good! hehe I love the part where Erik says "For once I'm the true phantom of the opera" hahaha I could just imagine him saying it proudly with his chest puffed out trying to look extremly buff hahahahahaha okay lol I know it wasn't meant to be taken that way but that's just me for ya lol

Gonna read the next chapter!

* A B B Y *

Yay! i'm happy you are updating! Keep on truckin! he he he ^.^

~Dawn

Ugh...meanie. (I mean Sam)
Gr...

Other than that, this chapter was very good...
The horse is extremely cool.