Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: Counting - Page 1 of 3
wonderwall05
2009-08-12 . chapter 1
This was so beautiful. I love the concept of the counting.
smaginn
2009-06-25 . chapter 2
I think you should continue!! It is a pity Cho, Fred and Lisa aren't saved. ): x Smaginn
RuBiAx
2008-12-14 . chapter 2
realy interesting... and deep...
good work!
femme fetal.
2008-06-20 . chapter 2
amazing.
nothing else to discribe your writing.
just amazing.
schneebly
2008-03-14 . chapter 2
Shit, I'm crying now. This was heartwrenchingly beautiful. Agh, I'm lost for words.
Arabella Lee Smith
2007-10-27 . chapter 2
Very interesting! A good tale. A soul saved. I really like what you quoted from the Bhagavad Gita. I believe in reincarnation, and whatever harm we do in this life we experience in another. Draco is begining his rehabilitation.

Thank you for sharing this story.
hotncold93
2007-08-14 . chapter 2
Wow. I cried AGAIN. You have a gift for writing amazing stories. :)
alizaleven
2007-07-17 . chapter 2
Oh wow... I'm nearly crying here.. in the library at my school LOL. That was very emotional. I love the pov from Draco it was amazing. Thank you so much for sharing!

Ali
Silidons
2007-02-03 . chapter 2
Beautifully written, it made my eyes well up :)

So sad, and written in a very moving way.

*~Silidons
Varietygirl9143
2007-01-30 . chapter 2
the whole jumping from POV to POV sounds a lot like some sort of 6 degrees theory... v. interesting.
exclamatorypoint
2007-01-15 . chapter 2
Oh. Boo. Now I feel stupid for submitting that slightly lengthier-than-usual review for the first chapter after realizing - whoops! - that wasn't the end, a second chapter exists.

Well, anyway. Moving on with the actual review...

In my opinion, if you combine these two chapters together to make one long oneshot, with the first chapter coming in as flashbacks plus a long-ish prologue from Hermione's POV, I'm certain it'll turn out lovely. Because that way, it won't seem so cut and abrupt.

As for that third chapter you're thinking of from Hannah's POV, I think you should either reserve that idea for another story (with only a few slight, vague references to this story) or abandon it completely. All would not be lost if you chose the latter; everything else you've written in this story and others more than makes up for it.

Then again, it's your story. I'm just offering my opinion and recommendations. Whatever you decide, I'll keep this story on my story alert list (though I know that by now, the chances of you updating this story seems to be almost nonexistent; you last updated in 2005) and I'll respect and support you until the day you stop writing. (And a bit more after that, actually. Your stories are that good. I particularly love The Year Of The Spiders and The Nietzsche Classes.)

TR
Tainted Rhapsody (notloggedin)
2007-01-14 . chapter 1
Frankly, I'm surprised that there are less than 100 reviews on this one.

I lovelovelove that quote at the bottom.
yourmomismyheart
2006-11-23 . chapter 1
This is REALLY GOOD.
I have some sort of strange addiction to angst.
Really, though, it was great.
=]
wover30
2006-11-14 . chapter 2
This fic is so touching! It made me cry! Great job, keep up the great work! If you decide to be an author, I think you would make a great one! I'd definetly read your book!

:oP
Maree16
2006-07-06 . chapter 2
i love the way you wroght both of the chapters and i think you should defenetly continue!
Return to Top