Dammit, your writing is that elusive star I wish to have. It is right in front of me, the very example of what I wish I could write, and yet so very far from me.

While I cannot have it, I can admire it. You harness the power very wisely. Gorgeous. Utterly gorgeous.

I feel very content to have read such a story.

Well, that was certainly rather bittersweet. Rather nicely done, though.

What is RIGHT with this story? I mean, it is absolutely ridiculous that Aragorn and Legolas would have an affair, I can't believe you would even think such an idea. You have absolutely killed the friendship between the elf and man, by turning it into a gay love affair? Well done, for ruining my viewing of the film trilogy whenver Legolas and Aragorn are present.

That was awesome. Great stuff :)

omg awsome story! great job!

Oh, that was good... extremely well written, it made my heart ache. And I absolutely love the way you portrayed Gimli here, very true to canon. Well done.

That was incredible. Well done on writing such a good one shot.

I was really excited when i saw this recent update. Welcome back, I'm so glad. I suppose we can all expect lots more good fanfic now.

This story really embodies the mood; grief, love and Gimli's understanding.

I've always viewed the Legolas/Aragorn relationship as a little less explicit. But that was exquisite anyway.

I love it, thanks for sharing this.

I mean Gimli is often neglected. I'm pleased you gave him some gravity here, I'm certain he appreciates it too.

kit.

That was absolutely beautiful. This is the first time I've ventured into the LOTR fandom in a VERY long time and I was so pleasantly surprised to find this! This is so beautifully written and I love the last line. This is great; it's off to be added to my favorite's list so I can come back to it and read it often!

Wow :?

I knew there was a good reason why I loved reading your stories.

Amazing. You encorporate so well your four characters- Gimili's musings on silence and Earth, Legolas' greif, Aragorn himself, and Gimli's discovery of them. Aided by powerful imagery and perfectly in the style of 'old', this piece really deserves celebration. Some of your sentences are so beautiful and fraught with meaning, I want to copy paste them and keep them forever. I'm going to see what else you have written.