NO! NO GODAMMIT NO! WHAT THE FUCK?!?!? WHYD U DO THAT?!??! DUDE!! FUCK MELANIE!!
-sigh- ok, thats fine. Dude, why?! You made me cry! That was a fucked up ending! Make an epiloque! Just assure me those two SOMEHOW end up together! in heaven, in a next life, I dont care! This is so heartbreaking! Urgh...
Well, anyway, you're a damn amazing writer. Respect. I loved and and hate it at the same time. Again, great job.

I love this fanfic and all... (this is like my fourth time reading it now - I think i've commented somewhere on here before), but there should totally be an alternate ending! C'mon. Please? You know you want to. So many people have requested one. It'd be awesome if you did do one.
No matter how many times I read this, it still makes me massively sad. D; Gogogoalternatehappyending!

Oh no =[
That's just sad, Kyle and Stan are meant to be together ! I hate Mrs Broflovski for tearing them apart, and Ike for disowning Kyle as a brother !
This story was pretty much amazing, and i didn't expect that ending at all. =[
Well done ! =D

Yey ! Kyle and Stan are together ! ^^
Aw, poor Kenny, liking the Stacey chick, and not actually getting to her =[

Yey ! Go kenny, the sorta peace-maker !

Aww ! Poor Stan =[

I hate u, dude. I hate u so fuckin much. U made me cry!! I'm fucking CRYING!! WTH! this isnt real! its fanfiction! I keep telling myself that! but its not helping!! GODDAMMIT!

SO well written.
And the epilogue was stunning. I for one LOVED the ending. I would have gladly settled for a Stan/Kyle marriage but
it's refreshing to see them not get each other,
even if it's tragic.
I loved what you did with Cartman too, again a refreshing
change. Thank you for an excellent story.

i hate it! you make me cry and i thought they would be together.. i dont hate the story although i really feel awkward about the 'sex' thing(always been) but i love the story! just the end was .. ugh! i hate why MELANIE has to marry him! shoo2! X(

i liked the story but i kinda hated the ending but overall the story was realy good

I'M CRYING RIGHT NOW! i fucking HATE you! Do and alternate ending or I will get all my friends to post hate mail!

I know this is a completed story, but I have to add it to favorites regardless. It is simply amazing. You hit the nail on the head with relationships. Especially these ever so tricky ones.

I must say, amazing job. I loved every second of it.

Oh no. Sad ending again. Thanks God they are at least all alive. Just kidding, I was reading Fighting The Truth before this. This is another really, really good story. I don’t read a lot of fan fic, but I know when I see a good writer.

I love you. Sad ending, but at least they are all alive...

I read this story awhile ago and I could never find it again, but I'm so pumped that I did. It's so beautiful and sad and amazing. Just, damn...thank you so much for writing this, honestly. It's incredible.