Reviews for New Roads and Secret Gates

Reviews For: New Roads and Secret Gates

Dagger 2007-01-05 ch 12, anon.	abuseVery nice little ficlets. You almost made me cry again (not he first story i read from you :)
demeter d 2006-07-26 ch 12,	abuseI followed your suggestion in one of your SofA stories and found you here, too. This is so sweet. did not Frodo after all tell Sam he had left him everything that he himself might have been? A relationship as strong as theirs became when they were grown must have had deep roots. Lovely picture!
Lady Lalaith 2006-07-25 ch 12, anon.	abuseSquee! Another adorable hobbit fic! I loved this one, and this is most likely my new favorite in this collection. I can't wait to hear more from you. And, yes, Frodo most definitely deserves some happy foreshadowing this time!
Sabishii-Taijiya 2006-05-19 ch 11,	abuseHooray, I open my email and there is a story alert inside! Hmm, the last six reviews have been from me as well. I loved this chapter; I got quite emotional at the end. I believe post-quest Valinor fics may be my favorite now. A fantasic job, although I do expect that from you after reading the last ten chapters. ;) -Lady Lalaith
Lady Lalaith 2006-02-22 ch 10, anon.	abuseBeautiful. No one ever really thinks about the Mumakil as having feelings or thoughts, but they do, and your fic helps remind people of that. You did a great job. :) -Lady Lalaith
Lady Lalaith 2006-01-18 ch 9, anon.	abuseCan it be? Another hobbit fic! ^^ I think that you captured the characters in this fic better than in any of your other ones. It was as if Tolkien was writing it, and that is not something I say often. Great, great, GREAT job, and I can't wait to read more of your work soon. :) -Lady Lalaith
Lady Lalaith 2006-01-11 ch 8, anon.	abuseHeh... I'm too lazy to sign in. ^^ This is great. I tried to write something short, and it didn't turn out too nicely. This, however, is great. It has voice, emotion, and a hobbit. I couldn't ask for more! -Lady Lalaith
Sabishii-Taijiya 2005-12-16 ch 7,	abuseNot to seem impatient, but I was waiting for a fic to mention Frodo. I'm an incurable Frodo fan. -laughs- Great job, and I think you found a very good pairing with this fic and that particular song. -Lady Lalaith
Lady Lalaith 2005-11-16 ch 6, anon.	abuseThis is my favorite one so far. Pippin is so cute and understanding for his age. I haven't read your other story, but I should. This is great, and is going into my favorites for sure. -Lady Lalaith
Lady Lalaith 2005-11-15 ch 5, anon.	abuseOh, this is too funny! I have had countless problems with Spellcheck when I write, and I do agree that poor Mary... er... Merry has the worst of it. And I must say, I don't know what a Fro do is. It sounds like a hairstyle. -laughs- -Lady Lalaith
ArcherGal2932 2005-10-02 ch 1,	abuseEs bastante interesante. Muy bien, senorita! Lo siento, tu eres en espanol una. Okay, I'll stop with the Spanish. By the way, I said your writing was very intersting, you did a good job, and sorry, I am in Spanish 1. ;) This piece definitely did a wonderful job in explaining what perhaps happened after Smeagol murdered his cousin. Somewhat creepy ending, very nice. I like. -ArcherGal2932
ArcherGal2932 2005-10-02 ch 3,	abuseVery short, but sweet. You will write more on this, you say? Oh, good! "What voice is it that speaks among the stones..." very good, I enjoyed it. -ArcherGal2932
ArcherGal2932 2005-10-02 ch 2,	abuseA beautiful ficlet...I am very pleased with your work with Gimli's passing. Your writing is very much...um, Dwarvish! lol But honestly, it does sound like Gimli is talking, and that is a very good thing. I love how authors can write one-sided conversations as well as this. Very good job, and thanks for writing. -ArcherGal2932
Lady Lalaith 2005-09-29 ch 2, anon.	abuseNot at all too vague. I likes this one, for it tells of what happens after the War, in Valinor, very well, whereas most stories of this genre fail miserably. I'll still await an update. ;) -Lady Lalaith
Sabishii-Taijiya 2005-09-17 ch 1,	abuseIndeed, this is very good. Sometimes, I can't help feeling sorry for poor Smeagol. Your writing has a flow to it, it is very hard to explain. I shall be awaiting an update eagerly. -Lalaith

Return to Top