 Silkylion10 2008-04-29 . chapter 10Wow...I don't know what to say (or write for that matter)... |
 Claudia 2005-09-29 . chapter 1 I always wondered what if...when book 7 is out and I would turn out to be wrong about the end, the chance is next to nothing- but.., but then it´s easy. I will put "7" in the shelf and leave it there forever, then, getting myself a nice glass of the elf-made,have a seat, smile and reread "Birdie and Rat". This prospect comforts me for the future, everything will turn out well! |
 Padawan Jan-AQ 2005-09-25 . chapter 8Sorry, too much. You had a good beginning, but it developed into the type of story that I'm not looking for. Just thought that I should tell you so you don't wonder what happened. |
 Padawan Jan-AQ 2005-09-25 . chapter 3I love your rewriting of canon history. :) Great writing in general, really intense and moving. I love Snape being a spider animagus. The dream was awesome. in the earlier chapter, I felt that Snape was too OOC, but it seems better now. |
 duj 2005-09-24 . chapter 10a happy ending. Snape has appointed some crazy teachers :)) |
 Strega Brava 2005-09-23 . chapter 8 I like the Draco you've portrayed. I hope there is more to him than just arrogant bastard Malfoy spawn in canon. Book 7 will tell. I also like how you ended this chapter. In all, nicely done...I'm really liking this tale you're spinning. |
 Strega Brava 2005-09-23 . chapter 7 This chapter made me sniffle although the more light-hearted ending made me feel better. Good job. Poor Harry. |
 duj 2005-09-22 . chapter 6The skin-phones were a creative addition. |
 Strega Brava 2005-09-21 . chapter 6 I like the argument at the end but my favourite part is the bit about Apparating Paramedics. That was bloody brilliant. |
 duj 2005-09-21 . chapter 5Nice to see Snape being appreciated for a change. |
 duj 2005-09-21 . chapter 4I sometimes wonder whether Draco was hurt worse than JK let on. Just because he made the most of it to annoy Harry and Ron doesn't mean it was all faked. And the report that he sometimes slipped the sling off could simply mean that the pain and muscle weakness was variable rather than constant. |
 duj 2005-09-21 . chapter 3Interesting turn of events though hard to reconcile with Hagrid's inability to keep secrets and Snape's PoA conviction in Sirius's guilt. Did someone obliviate them? |
 Strega Brava 2005-09-20 . chapter 5 Oh you just know I love Carmelina Fury.
::grin::
Seriously, Simon is another character that I really like and I think you made some great name choices. Commander Severus Snape? Excuse me while I swoon. |
 Strega Brava 2005-09-20 . chapter 4 This won't come as a surprise to you but I really like Lucie DeGrace. She is NOT a Mary Sue because she has a flawed past and is refreshingly imperfect. |
 hermionebabe06 2005-09-20 . chapter 3yay good story more more more hehe hyper is fun! |