Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: A Worthy Dream
Djinn1
2006-02-18 . chapter 1
A friend recommended you to me. I'm not disappointed. This is an amazing treatment of two shows I grew up watching. It's dark and twisted, doing to two fluffy shows what I'd never expect but really enjoyed. I love the texture and the backstory you give Samantha. Fantastic work.
Village-Mystic
2005-09-29 . chapter 1
Okay, dear Yorick, this is actually the first story of yours that I read a few days ago. I tried to submit a review and log-in at the same time and it crashed. So I'll try to remember as best as I can, as this fine story deserves some feedback.

First off, I was expecting a little more of a humor story, but you did your drama, mythology and angst very well.

I'd be interested in reading more in this "universe"

I like your origin for the immortal witches, I think everyone had their own theory. Mine was that the first generation of these witches were half-fairy and half-human.

I like your thoughtfulness about Samanthana's origin as a temple preistess, and the thought that she and the others have married mortals on many occasions.

My question to you about what you made up versus what was in the television series is the part about meeting future and past selves. It sounds a bit like something they've done a few times in the "Charmed" series, but I don't recall it from "Bewitched". If you write more in this universe, I'd appreciate if you went into how this first occured for some of the characters instead of saying it matter-of-fact existing.

I also liked your decision, given the circumstances, that Serena was just an alter-ego for Samantha.

Thanks for sharing the tale. Hope to see some more work from you.

Village Mystic aka Rachel
Return to Top