Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: Hollow Soldiers
Owl Emporium
2008-08-26 . chapter 1
This was really sweet! The only probalem was the grammar...it wasn't that good. However, this was still good. Great job! (:

Angelica
Kileaiya
2006-08-09 . chapter 1
I liked it, very nice.
Angel sumoritos
2005-11-16 . chapter 1
Wow, I really liked this great fic
Jonathan Hirst
2005-10-26 . chapter 1
Another top story from a writer who seems to really tap into Lupin and Tonk's interesting relationship. The dialogue is witty and believable. An all round brill job.
KYLZ
2005-10-14 . chapter 1
AWESOME! Awesome awesome awesome. Did I mention this is awesome?! AWESOME
devillish angel
2005-10-12 . chapter 1
it was gud and i think u should add another chapter becasue only as u start writing will u get the hang of things and it will slowly improve dont wworry i am backing u up 100%
Lady Salmalin-Holmes-Darcy
2005-10-11 . chapter 1
Really cute!! No one shot! More! update it second chapter we demand it!
slightly so.
2005-10-09 . chapter 1
Thank you for making those changes! It is much better and easier to read this time over. There are a few grammar and punctuation mistakes that would improve the piece, and I find that when you have dialogue, it flows smoother if you go to the next line when someone new speaks.

Sorry I'm being such a stickler for grammar.

Anyway, I really liked Tonks' reaction to her falling, that was incredibly satisfying and revealing about the emotional state she'd been in before, and how she is now. Yay!
slightly so
2005-10-08 . chapter 1
hey, nice job.
BUT...
it would be much easier to read and appreciate if you formatted it in the usual style, with paragraphs, no double spaces except between paragraphs, (it's not really an essay, is it?)
Also, when you have quotation marks, the punctuation should go on the inside, so '"your hair it's turning pink",' should be "your hair it's turning pink,"

At least that's the way I normally see it, i think French has different punctuation rules, but yeah...
I'd love it if you could repost it in paragraph fomat! THis story has potential.. I'm just fickle and unable to concentrate properly on a story if it's in a different format.
cassie89
2005-10-08 . chapter 1
cute:)
jynkyg
2005-10-07 . chapter 1
that was a good idea and great story but you could work on the structure of your writing, like using paragraphs, and the dialogue was kind of hard to read. good job!
MsHellFire2005
2005-10-07 . chapter 1
I really like the plot. The way it was written. it was very passinate Keep writting.
CryptJo
2005-10-07 . chapter 1
I don't really know the characters or their backgrounds, but this is a well written, enjoyable piece! I hope to read more of your works soon. Keep up the good work!

Jo
Return to Top