Share/Save/Bookmark
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Reviews For: Stolen Child - Reviews: Page 1 of 3

Perspicacity
2008-07-16
ch 4,
abuseI enjoyed this piece a great deal. It was deliciously sad and potent, tears shed in solitude. You wove the poem elegantly into the story and your piece was just the right length.

The only thing I'd change is I felt there was a little too much description of what happened to everyone in the end. We could have heard just about the fates of the very closest (Ginny, Hermione, and Ron, maybe Albus) dying and it would have sufficed--the sense of loss Harry would feel would justify the poem. I feel the slightly too long exposition at the end broke the tone of the piece slightly.

But this is a very minor thing. In all, it was a well written, thoroughly enjoyable piece.
EvilspyAchacia
2008-07-13
ch 4,
abuseYou are amazing, even if you did pair Harry with Ginny.

Kira
ominix
2008-07-08
ch 4,
abusegreat work
emodragon
2008-03-04
ch 4,
abuseI'm glad I found this. It was wonderful. Poor Harry! Everone we loved died. :(

Faeries are awesome!
excessivelyperky
2008-03-01
ch 1,
abuseNow, if the fairies had fetched him from the cupboard under the stairs...Petunia would probably not run fast enough to catch him.

Very good.
yllom21
2006-09-30
ch 4,
abuseInteresting story, well written! I think you wrote Harry really well and this piece is exteremly creative. Wonderful job.
EowynSaule
2006-06-12
ch 1,
abuseI love that song... And I think the story you wrote with it is very cute. :)
galleena
2006-04-21
ch 4,
abuseThat is so sad. And beautifual at the same time.

Well, I won't mar the effect by blabbering on in a review but it was a truly gorgeous story.
kia
2006-04-06
ch 4, anon.
abusei swear i cried . that was so sweet! I love you! * cries*
AgentPersephone
2006-01-12
ch 1,
abuseIt reminds of a story book I read as a child - The Swan Sister. Nice, made me wish I was there.
LassyD
2005-12-08
ch 4, anon.
abuseWell, At the time, there were only three. But regardless, I still love it. I do like the Luna Harry interaction. I think you've done well. Skittles to you :-)
Wolven Spirits
2005-12-02
ch 4,
abuseVery touching :) Brings a sad smile to your face. Great job^_^ I loved it! You definitely get a sense of longing, and peace in the end^^*. Props to you!
BellonaBellatrix
2005-11-29
ch 4,
abuseWell, now. This is brilliant, and I must say quite original. The Faeries, eh...and of course, Luna was grand. I like the touch about her father. Yes, it would be Harry's time to rest, after he had given so much.
AngelAriel
2005-11-14
ch 4,
abuseA good short story...Fill with sadness through the whole story, but still, you have brought hope in the end...And I think that , you can contin. to write this...

AngelAriel
Katsy17
2005-11-09
ch 4,
abuseaw that was so kool!
Return to Top