Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: Gone
Nath
2007-03-05 . chapter 1
Teyla's POV is good.
Just a thing, I know John and McKay have the ancient gene, but I'm not sure Teyla and Ford have it. In "the eye", Carson was the only one able to fly the jumper.
Anyway, good job.
Devil Theory
2005-12-06 . chapter 1
Cool, i love fics with characters thoughts in them, and it's so wonderful emotional, just the way i like them.

Good job, sp-hanking good is a silly way of putting it.
CharmedAli
2005-11-08 . chapter 1
oh, good, well written
Dr. Dredd
2005-10-19 . chapter 1
It's an interesting look at the tragic choices John and Teyla had to make. I think John would have been tempted to stay anyway, even if Teyla had not made the request, once he saw people culled right in front of him. It was at that point in the episode that he changed from "we have to consider Atlantis at all costs" to "we've got to do something to take these guys down."

One point I don't think John considered, though. Would Teyla have even been able to fly the jumper? (I don't know if it requires the gene at this point, or if anyone can fly it once it's active.) If she were not able to fly it, then John bears even more responsibility to get them safely back to Atlantis. Even if it means abandoning the culling.

Good job.
Jennifer
2005-10-19 . chapter 1
Hey, nice. Liked it very much. I always thought that was an oddly OOC scene with them on the planet - thanks for filling in a bit and making some sense!

I hope you get your glitch figured out! Love to see more from you!
Cpt. Ritter
2005-10-19 . chapter 1
Another great story by you, have you tried a different web browser or using a public computer. Just an idea, not sure if it helps. Keep writing.
Only Memories
2005-10-19 . chapter 1
This was awesome. I believed that this is what Teyla really felt. Kind of this there were more Sheyla stories with their scenes from Letters from Pegasus. Anyways great job and hope to read more from you.

~Tabby Lynn~
AthosianGirl
2005-10-19 . chapter 1
I love when someone appraoches a story from Teyla's point of view. She is my favorite character and I think you did a great job of delving into her thoughts, specially about Sheppard. I always did wonder what went through her mind when John went out into the culling.
Lennexa
2005-10-19 . chapter 1
Wow. Well written! I liked it very much. It's nice to read something that goes in depth into Teyla's feelings. She's so calm all the time it's easy to disregard what an effect things like this must have on her!
Return to Top