I just read all 37 chapters, and this will be one of my favorites. perhaps, in my top 3 favorite fics i've ever read. i love the character you have written and how she lives through the ages. i especially love all the high elves she encounters and how she is related to them, and what i most love about your story is how you have her live through the history of elves (post fall of gondolin). it was such a tragic ending but i loved it nonetheless.

thank you so much. it was such a pleasure reading this.

poor us north americans... our cities are gray and clumpy :'(

not a bad beginning. I am identifying with this character.

Beautifully done. Even though the work spans years, literally, you managed to keep it somewhat consistent, and you managed to keep Eruanna very down to earth and believable. Nicely researched and wonderfully canon- I approve- and props for the utmost creativity and originality in this kind of fic. Not sure if you're still updating or not, but this is headed to my favorites.

Loved the story. I knew it'd have a sad ending, but stil . . . Great job

I just finished your story and what can I say, I loved it. I hope you still plan on more chapters because this is really good.

I so want you to continue with this as there is so much story to tell and this was a very unique spin at a most unusual time of ME.

Hay this is a great story but please update asap

I have just discovered this wonderful story and have just finished reading it twice. Please update soon...

Wow! This story is fantastic! It is one of the better 1st person stories I've read. I really enjoy how real your characters feel. It's like you've tapped into the real Tolkien spirit, but enhanced it in your own unique way. This story makes me greedy for more chapters! I sincerely hope you haven't abandoned this story because it truly is wonderful!

Keep up the awesome work! :)

And if you can, please update soon!

Just found this and I love it! looking forward to the next chapter!

Fantastic story, can't wait to read more!

I'd love to read this thoroughly, but I find the formatting and scarcity of punctuation oppressive to my eyes and mind. What I've read seems thoroughly researched and more than a little interesting, so I hope you have the time and inclination to make the editorial changes that would make the story accessible to squinty-eyed twits like me.

wow,this is amazing! i can't wait until your next post! I love your style of writing. you are one of the few authors who can pull off the elves so perfectly. mostly they don't seem to feel right... they sortg of make them too human. and also, i'm really impressed with your knowledge of the elves! Can you actually speak Quenya or Sindarin, or do you just know little bits? anyway. This is an awsome story, and i CAN'T wait to read the rest!

I know she's been slowly forgetting, but still, wouldn't it be nice if she could give a bit of hope to Thranduil? It's a long way to Greenwood even if Thranduil knows where to go. After all, what's the use of being a modern-day girl in ME if you don't know a thing about Tolkien canon - you might as well have created an original ME girl?