Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Help
Reviews For: Harry Potter and the Third Party - Reviews: Page 1 of 20
T-person 2009-01-03 . chapter 65
Hey! I'm still here, sorry I wasn't able to review earlier, I've still got stuff to do after and around the new year. I'm interested in where this is going to go now that you've continued to update.

Hope to see more soon and Happy New Year!

T-person
purebloodprince 2008-12-28 . chapter 60
i just saw the origin date of this fic, 2005...you must have really liked this story to do it for so long. I really don't know how you managed to keep this up unless you're like a teenager or something that has nothing better to do, no offence.
purebloodprince 2008-12-28 . chapter 58
honestly the only reason I have kept reading so long is because I had nothing better to do, but seriously with each passing chapter I disliked the story more and more. The major problem is that there's no real plot to it, just alot of lame sub plots that aren't really related, it's pretty much like a tv drama. If that's your intention then you have done great...if not then I can only say you have a lot of work to do. Your characterization was not only ooc, but it made no sense it didn't follow logic and I'm curious as to what you were thinking in having this whole marietta edgecomb thing have such a huge role. I only read this for the of beign a Harry/Cho shipper, but this really just wasn't worth it. Did you write all this on the go, organic write, or do you have some sort of scheme that you are following because this has no sense of direction at all. Um, well I'm not going to say I like this story or that its good but I do commend your effort.
Mstrydude 2008-12-28 . chapter 65
ALRIGHT FINALY YOU UPDATED it is about time. Man i was almost ready to loose hope but THANK GOD YOU UPDATED. And you did a good job to. anyway ty for finaly updating it is rare i find a story like this.
Randi 2008-12-27 . chapter 1
Hey, this is really good. I'm impressed at your writing ability. Maybe i'll read more in the future but like I promised I read the first chapter.
LeAn 31 2008-12-24 . chapter 10
Wow... too many typos or wrongspelling in this chapter like...

"Ma
LeAn 31 2008-12-23 . chapter 4
Wow... Harry's OC in this story... mostly this chapter
LeAn 31 2008-12-23 . chapter 2
I guess this explains my question then...
LeAn 31 2008-12-23 . chapter 1
Good start but... how the hell are they going to hold a funeral for Sirius when he fell on the veil??
Mstrydude 2008-07-24 . chapter 64
UPDATE DAMNIT UPDATE its not fair that i must see such a good fanfic go so long without an update PLEAS UPDATE
WHO R U PEAPLE 2008-07-08 . chapter 64
this is like the coolst fic iv read its SO FREAKEN AWSOME how ever you havnt updated pls up date or ill go insain (oh tolate) pleas update like now
scott 2008-01-26 . chapter 4
story was not too great. I do not think that harry would just sit down and take being slapped by the weasel. I just don't understand how harry can go hate dumbledore and be fine with being slapped. I just does not make any sense. I hate pansy harry's. Sorry if the review seems to harsh.
wiccan believer 2007-10-24 . chapter 3
Wow that was great you actually got me to feel i haven't read any other story from fan writers that did as well as you.i think you almost did as well as J.K
FSL 2007-09-19 . chapter 12
Very INteresting.. :P
FSL 2007-09-19 . chapter 11
lloll..
Harry's a n ass.. :P
Return to Top