Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Help
Reviews For: A Tale of Erestor and Rather Large Books
Elenor GreanLeEf 2008-10-12 . chapter 1
I love this story. It's taken me forever to review, but I think I have read it about 10 times or more. I'm surprised you don't have more reviews.
Nelarun 2007-03-14 . chapter 1
Has Elrond been drugged or is he just completely clueless. I loved it!

Nela
Ponytail Goddess 2007-02-28 . chapter 1
LOL!
Arilien 2007-02-27 . chapter 1
Once again you have shown pure comedy :D I felt just like Erestor today when I was cleaning my er... THE art room. I spent a good long time trying to get everything cleaned up (I'm sick of looking at palettes and brushes spread out everywhere) and pretty soon... it was messy again...
lomion 2005-12-05 . chapter 1
abso**inglutely awesome
Erestor 2005-11-01 . chapter 1
Very amusing in a rather painful way. It's always terrible when clueless, careless people completely the product of hours of hard work.

I loved the way Erestor kept on calling it 'his' library(very funny) and I liked the line "He was complaining about how the curtains in the library clash with the tapestry. How crazy is that?". It suddenly seemed like *such* a Glorfindel thing to be complaining about, which demonstrates good writing on your part.
any 2005-10-31 . chapter 1
i thought it was good very funny i sympathies with him. i dont know why but i have the strange idea that he should stop sobbing uncontrollably at elronds words and then go attack/get revenge on glorfindel. i can see a continuation to this.
Piratica 2005-10-31 . chapter 1
That was cruel! To Erestor, I mean. I spotted a couple of spelling mistakes (numinous, for example. I think you meant numerous.)

Otherwise, it was okay. I like how you kept reminding us that it actually WASN'T Erestor's library.
Return to Top