 AuroraExecution 2007-12-27 . chapter 1*love*
Wow. Just, wow. I've been browsing through your works, and this is one of my favorites so far. I also like your Untitled Celeborn fic as well...and some of the stuff about Sirius (what I understand, of course, since I've not finished Harry Potter).
Anyway. Cheers. Please keep writing. ^^
Hugs,
AE |
 Jabraille 2007-03-08 . chapter 1I was fortunate enough to see a review you'd left on a vastly inferior story, and I followed your name back to this story.
This is amazingly beautiful. I wish I could describe the feelings it evokes in me as eloquently as you describe the feelings in Faramir. Beautifully done indeed. |
 Prieda Solo 2007-02-21 . chapter 1Oh I'm crying again. seriously this is wierd, i usually never cry at fanfiction.
but this is gorgeuos. so beautiful. i think i broke down around number three.
and the end is so beautiful too. the more i think about it, the more those two are perfect for each other. |
 ithiliengirl108 2006-02-26 . chapter 1Wow! I really enjoyed this! I really don't see how anyone could maim you or think its idiotic. |
 MidenianScholar 2006-02-23 . chapter 1Oh, I like muchly. I hadn't thought of that, but it's a very good idea to compare Finduilas..es... :) |
 Dimfuin 2005-11-07 . chapter 1 I thought it was quite nice. It shows the development his character went through. |
 nautika 2005-11-04 . chapter 1I like it! I think I'd have liked it better if you'd left out the line "(He had never really wanted to be Turin.)" because you'd already convinced me he did want to be. Aside from that, I think it was really good! |
 Patty 2005-11-03 . chapter 1 Why on earth would anyone maim you, particularly me?
I think your story is great, extremely enjoyable.
I felt so sorry for Faramir, his yearning to love and
be loved. Eowyn filled his heart and arms and I'm singing joyfully! Yay!! |
 Middie 2005-11-03 . chapter 1 (Ish too lazy to log in ;>.>)
It's quite poetic, actually. It sounds like a one-shot deal, though, because the words are so beautifully strung together. However, seconds would be nice, if they could measure up to this chapter. I would love to read anything more to this!
Middie |
 Arahiril 2005-11-03 . chapter 1I think it's lovely!! And I think the premise is very clever and interesting too. So like Faramir. ^^ |
 Evenstar Elanor 2005-11-03 . chapter 1Again, I wonder sometimes what goes on in that head of yours.
When I first read the lay of Turin Turambar, I actually thought of the Finduilas/Finduilas connection, but I never analyzed it that closely.
It's great! Haha you're not TOO much of an idiotic premise, and if anyone tries to maim you, just tell me.
Great analysis and writing!
And I must admit, the last bit with Eowyn is good, even if it should be me in that mantle and not her... Those Rohirrim... argh |
 Depprium 2005-11-03 . chapter 1This isn't idiotic at all! It was really good and I enjoyed reading it. :) |
 Seriously Wrong 2005-11-03 . chapter 1That was absolutely beautiful and well thought out. Such a nice change from the usual nonsense that intrudes on this genre. As to being an idiotic premise, far from it my dear; it was only that someone far thinking needed to bring the parralells to our attention. I say a job well done and thank you for posting. |
 Anais 2005-11-03 . chapter 1 Darling, wish more premises on this site were as "idiotic" as this one! |
 steelelf 2005-11-03 . chapter 1 Sheer beauty- not idiotic at all! Wonderful! |