|
|
| Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search | Login Register Extras |
| anonymous 2007-11-26 ch 1, anon. | abuseI absolutely love this fic. The beginning was so real and canon and by the end it was so...so...so... *gives up and starts bawling* TAT |
| Empress-Dragon 2007-06-18 ch 1, | abusewow it was awsome. both sad and sweet. |
| The Wandering Swordsman 2007-02-14 ch 1, | abuseThat was good! I never read this kind of plot before! This was great! It kinda' teared me up a little (I'm SUPER sensitive...) but otherwise, it was awesome!! |
| kiki 2006-10-30 ch 1, anon. | abusethis fic is AWESOME you did a GREAT job with it |
| mka 2006-10-17 ch 1, anon. | abusethis lovely line /"Happy birthday to me.” Zoro muttered moving forward./ as well as the rest of the fic were simply magnificent i loved it they style of writing and well evyrhting im speechless i love |
| Some Girl101 2006-08-23 ch 1, | abuseI agree with everything Yuki Kokoro said, and it's pretty much what I wanted to say. :) Except I actually did cry a little. But that might just be because my eyes sting for some reason. |
| Yuki Kokoro 2006-04-30 ch 1, | abuseOh this is just so *painful*. I found myself rushing through the ending and wanting to just run from this and close the window, but it really does deserve a review. The way the whole thing is written looking back nostalgically sends you to a place where you're looking back at the past and really hoping for a happy moment for it to end. But you really don't spare your readers here. Watching Zoro get old and just... lose things in these short little clips was *hard*. It especially hurt that even the "happy" ones weren't really all that happy. In most of them he either is alone or somehow... seems alone. I'm in such a mood that I almost started crying at the end, even though that's nearly unheard of for me, let alone over such a short piece. I agree with that other reviewer who mentioned that One Piece just has such an eternal feel. It seems like it will last forever and these characters will just live their lives out together. If they die they should die fighting for one another, seeing Zoro alone and only having dreams of them to look back on... I don't know. This one just hit me hard, especially after all the other lovely bickering Sanji/Zoro I've been reading from you. My throat hurts, and I'm off to find something happy before I sleep but... this was amazing. Very nice writing. *wanders off.. slightly dazed* |
| akunohana 2006-02-25 ch 1, | abuseThis is amazing (but it's no surprise from you after all). The idea is original and it's brillantly made. I was very sad at the end like everyone, I guess (T__T) but it's really another great piece of yours. |
| genuinelies 2006-01-18 ch 1, anon. | abuseWow, that was effing sad. You need like, a pain warning. Nevertheless - great job :-). |
| FanFictionFan 2005-11-15 ch 1, anon. | abuseAnother graeat fic from you :D! Original idea, that of birthdays and structure. And as always, lurving the pairing (also interesting Yosaku and Johnny- never read that one!). aLTHOUGH the end was depressing to think of, OP seems eternal, and you never really want the dream to end -poignant phrase: "hair more silver than gold"- and yet, really REALLY good. Like always, one can only thank and congratulate you! |
| fyrbyrd 2005-11-15 ch 1, anon. | abuseThank you for the bit with Johnny and Yosaku. Love those two and with Zoro, even better |
| Omni-chan 2005-11-13 ch 1, | abuseYay Happy Birthday Zoro! Though I am sad at no hints of ZoNa. ::pouts:: |
| Jubin 2005-11-13 ch 1, anon. | abuseBrillant. Truly Brillant *__* |