Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Help
Reviews For: Redhead Hogwartian - Reviews: Page 1 of 5
Rachel1813 2008-12-06 . chapter 9
since no one else was updating, i thought i would reread one of my old favourites. This just happened to be the story i clicked on. i forgot how amazing this story was. thanks.
stxs 2008-08-16 . chapter 9
sequel?
Asterisks 2008-04-02 . chapter 9
aww hey at least you didn't kill sirus.
Haxan 2008-01-06 . chapter 1
This was a very enjoyable and entertaining crossover. I loved the idea about the origin of magic and how you used that to wrap up an exciting finale against the First. Brilliant imagination! Despite some inconsistencies such as the overly hostile Trio (Okay, granted they didn't trust the suspicious uber powerful new girl...But their behaviour just seemed a shade too aggressive at times. I mean hey, they poisoned poor Willow! And I have to wonder why she or the teachers didn't seek out her attackers afterward...) and the disappearing pet phoenix, I really found this a compelling well written story. Goodness knows, it's kept me up well past my bed time! Thank god it was complete!:D

Cheers for a great read!
faeriesinger 2007-08-06 . chapter 9
That was a really good story. I really enjoyed reading it. Well thought out. And I absolutely LOVE the tombstone inscription.
Malaskor 2007-06-03 . chapter 9
Nice story, but why the heck did you introduce a phoenix as her "pet" in the chapter dealing with her buying her supplies in Diagon Ally and then you never again mention / use it in the story?
Translucent Darkness 2007-04-15 . chapter 9
That was so sad! A very good story, but so sad!
Sean Mulligan 2007-02-21 . chapter 1
I am sorry that Willow died but this is definately a great fic.
NoMoreFanFic 2006-06-22 . chapter 9
Nice story!
mystic soilder 2006-06-08 . chapter 9
Beautiful story.
The Cardboard Moon 2006-03-12 . chapter 9
Miss the Willow. Love the tombstone.

Good work you. You have my approval,. and as I am a major ficsnob, that's saying something. *hugs*

Ta!
~Julie, the Cardboard Moon
Oddball-no.2 2006-03-11 . chapter 9
You can't just go around, killing off people's favourite characters, you know. I feel like crying! Meanie... Awesome fic though- very well thought through.
Momo and the Muses 2006-03-04 . chapter 9
*bursts into tears* OMG THAT'S SO SAD YET AMAZING! WAH!!
bigstu 2006-02-01 . chapter 9
excelent story I loved it Thanks for good read
bigstu 2006-02-01 . chapter 2
Harry what a idiot,thinks the world revolves around him,GOOD bstory though i like it
Return to Top