 Ziiz 2009-07-30 . chapter 1Were's the next chapter? |
 Vampwriter 2008-11-22 . chapter 1Wow. I like this. |
 Julianmon 2008-06-16 . chapter 1Even though I have no Idea what Alchemy thingy thing is I like this story very much. |
 Ryu_Vision 2008-02-25 . chapter 1 so when the next update man |
 Fast Frank 2007-07-02 . chapter 1 Good story, overall
However, protege does not mean prodigy. |
 ApocSM 2007-05-08 . chapter 1WOW! I LOVE THIS STORY, MUY BUENO! YOU DID A SUPERB JOB ON THE PLOT! UPDATE REAL SOON! |
 Kurt Baros aka The Falcon 2007-02-27 . chapter 1nice...very cool story i really liked this one also i dont think i seen a cross over like this one keep up the good work dude |
 Ten-Faced Paladin 2007-01-23 . chapter 1When are you going to update?! This is pretty good so far! |
 Virosa 2006-09-27 . chapter 1you are a very good writer andyour storys are grate but can you update a few of them soon PLZ
ttfn |
 New lord of darkness 2006-07-14 . chapter 1Very good, mate. When ya gonna update? |
 conlan0414863 2006-05-22 . chapter 1keep on typing and ill keep on reading |
 Nate River1 2006-04-12 . chapter 1I'm not normally a huge fan of crossovers, but this was a intersting mix so I though I'd check it out. I thought it to be pretty humerous and I've enjoyed what I've read.
The "scene" thing bugged my until I realized what it was you were doing.
I do have a couple of critiques, however.
First, on the author notes, please don't put them into the story like that especially those of a commentary nature. If you wish to have such commentary do it at the end. By adding those notes, it takes me out of the story which is frustrating. You detract from the quality of your story when you place author notes like that.
Second, on the dates. I'd suggest picking a time framework. Rather that just saying whatever is reasonable with yourself. I believe the Ranma series has a specific time framework already, but if you can't find one, just pick something. As long as you let the readers know you have done this and are consistent with yourself then it will be okay. As you have it now, it comes across as an unnecessary author's note and makes you look lazy.
But, as I said, I did enjoy your story so far and will read more if you decide to continue it. Nabiki seems a little OOC, but given what happened I expect that and as long as you cover what happened in the FMA world then its no big deal.
Finally, your grammar and spelling are good. I noticed a couple of typos, but there were only a few and other than that everything was okay. |
 Otritzi 2006-04-10 . chapter 1Nice crossover between FMA and Ranma. I couldn't tell from the summary that it was though. I hope you're going to continue this fic, it's quite enjoyable. |
 SotF 2006-02-23 . chapter 1Please write more of this, I like it so far. |
 ChaosRonin 2006-01-29 . chapter 1Awsome hope to see more of this story some time soon ^_^ |