Share/Save/Bookmark
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Reviews For: The Guardian in Spite of Herself - Reviews: Page 1 of 24

The Unicorn
2008-09-24
ch 1,
abuseHaving Uchiah Sassuke living with Yukiko, across the hall from Naruto is ridiculous and impossible for many different reasons including but not limited to:

-Unlike Naruto there'd be people competing for the privilege of housing Sassuke (for political reasons at the very least, although probably other reasons as well)

-The same people who'd have raised a fuss if the Hokage took care of Naruto would raise at least as much of a fuss if the Hokage has Sassuke living in close proximity to Naruto.

-Sassuke has several houses he could live in and the money to pay for a house keeper even without any money from some orphan's fund and that is probably what he'd wish to do.

The Unicorn
Wedge
2008-07-27
ch 12, anon.
abuseAWESOMENESS.

UPDATE PLZ KTHXBYE
GoldenRat
2008-07-14
ch 12,
abuseYay, sequel. Aftermath of Uchiha Massacre makes for interesting read. I look forward to reading about a Sasuke who isn't left alone, but's still an angsty teenager.
Liviania
2008-07-11
ch 12,
abuseI'm sad this story isn't high on the to be finished list. Several people recommended this series highly, and I agree with their judgement. It's an interesting twist, with well done OCs, and a plausible plot. (Who hasn't wondered about the Uchihas on missions?)

Livi
WalkingDisasters
2008-07-09
ch 12,
abuseThere's really not much to critize here, because it all seems so good - I'm captivated, definitely.

I do like how you've written this - it's all like an intricate web with all the details and people - it just works out so well!

Although, you tend to go, "Naruto's sister" a lot...

But still, it's a pretty good story. Are you going to write a book anytime soon? :)
Haruka-Hime
2008-06-07
ch 12,
abuseCan you tell me where you got your names from?
sophia666
2008-05-05
ch 12,
abuseWow... I guess Sasuke's decided to go missing-nin a lot earlier than in canon. Great chapter. Please update really soon.
sophia666
2008-05-05
ch 11,
abuseGreat chapter. I really do like Ginji and Eiji, as well as Tetsuko and Mitsu-chan, and I understand Ginji's reasoning, as well as Eiji's ideas. And the fact that he remembers 'humans were tools of their clans and villages, but not only tools; humans had minds and hearts and souls as well, and nobody should ever pretend otherwise'. I think that's really important. Kakashi, Naga and Kafunnokaze are funny, I hope Naga doesn't die if they find Itachi. Will Naruto and Sasuke really stay behind or go along with the caravan? Please update soon.
anony
2008-05-02
ch 12, anon.
abuseWow, this is really great! I am totally in love with these characters, even your original ones.

I think it's really interesting how Sasuke thinks about Yukiko--he calls Itachi "that man" and for a while he was calling her "the woman," although now it looks like she's graduated to "Naruto's sister." I guess even Sasuke in the depths of shock can't quite block Naruto into being just another obstacle...
Ashcat
2008-04-25
ch 12,
abuseIt was nice to see our main characters taking the lead again here. I'd missed Yukiko :) and I like Seichi as a character his quirks are interesting and are plausible. I also like how you're using Kurenai so far in this story.

Sasuke is an interesting addition to the mix but I think you're characterized him well. Naruto and his interplay feels authentic and I still feel bad for naruto here in the story he is still a kid :)

I find the idea behind the whole guy who will be assasinated interesting and why he's doing it but I think you had let him run away witht he story a bit in the previous chapters so it was nice to get a break. We don't have to know all the details about that story and if you're that into it maybe it should become a side story about the background reasons etc.

My critical comment is that you way overused "naruto's sister" as a tag for Yukiko in the last few paragraphs with Sasuke.

I really like how you've created the politics and infrastructure and world building into this - your work as an orig fic writer shows through but the subtly you normally use with it makes it nice and not distracting.
Inarae
2008-04-06
ch 12,
abuseHeh, I didn't know there was a sequal to Apartment Manager. What a nice way to end the weekend. It is wonderful, naturally, so thank you very much for writing and sharing. I was caught up in the story enough that I didn't pay attention to the writing, but I'll go back and reread it in a few days so I can give you a more analytic review. Have a good week, and thanks again!
White Blossoms
2008-03-31
ch 12,
abuseHey it was a great chapter sorry it took me such a long time to reveiw!! I just never seemed to be able to read and if I did I didnt get the chance to review!! But this chapter was great! I wonder what this realisation will do to Sasuke? Lol Seichi and Yukiko are a funny pair together their intteration is very interesting to read! In the sense of them together and around other people! I hope Naruto bounces back lol! Great chapter!

White Blossoms
feelingwhimsy
2008-03-25
ch 12, anon.
abuseFor some reason, I am ridiculously pleased that Akaro might be alive. xD; Ah, random attatchment to background characters.

In other news, very interested to see what Sasuke's thinking in not wanting to go back, etc,etc. I'll be keeping an eye on this. :]
RoxasIsReal13
2008-03-01
ch 12,
abuseEagerly awaiting an update.
hakuisagirl
2008-02-22
ch 12,
abusei loved the whole thing. the first story and this one. only complaint...i need more.
Return to Top