Share/Save/Bookmark
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Reviews For: Chronicles of war and peace

Gagan
2006-07-14
ch 2, anon.
abusegr8 action."Die u traitors".Well why do u feel sorry for including violent scenes.Anything realted to kyoto and the shinsengumi has to have violent scenes.
Who r we fighting? A really nice question.
I think sayuri-chan shud have dragged etsuko-san out the backdoor,but then she's ur charecter.You must have thought of a reason for it.
Gagan
2006-07-14
ch 1, anon.
abuseReally nice chapter.Enjoyed all of it.You have described sayuri and her family really nicely.
I think the sayuri's charecter is straight forward and has potential of accomplishing something.
But, dont u think instead of 'Hikaru-san' , u shud use 'Hikaru neesan' for brother.pardon me if i'm wrong(still confused what *chan* really stands for)
anon
2006-05-06
ch 1, anon.
abuseThat was lovely
Okitasgal
2006-05-03
ch 3, anon.
abuseWow... I loved this chapter. It was perfectly done! I'm beginning to like this girl, she seems so canon! Waiting for an update.
Okitasgal
2006-05-03
ch 2, anon.
abuseYes it was violent. Actually I was afraid she'd save the whole village and become a 'hero'. She's quite normal isn't she? It's interesting to see where this is going...
Okitasgal
2006-05-03
ch 1, anon.
abuseThat was a good start... I'm glad to see no hint of mary-sueness.

2006-03-24
ch 1, anon.
abuseWow... that was amazing... I never read something like that before!
nissepisse
2006-02-22
ch 2,
abuseKeep going, like where this is headin!
White Rabbit Tale
2005-12-29
ch 1,
abuseHm...well I like it. It seems like a fic that is going to revolve very much around the OC, which is fine if you do it right, and you certainly seem capable. The things i noticed about this fic is that it is fairly historically accurate and plausible.
Not much else to say but I love the tone of the narration. It isn't too flowery, but it certainly has its charm. I loved the last line, very ominous without being melodramatic.
So I see good, interesting things ahead for this fic!
maxy-chan
2005-12-25
ch 1,
abuseWell.. um.. it's quite a good start... but.. where is the RK cast?! ;__; it really doesn't have anything to do with the series ^_^; it's a good start, if you put them in the next chap, though!
Well, I guess I'll see!
Bye-bye!
Return to Top