Share/Save/Bookmark
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Reviews For: The Scales of Friendship

The Enchanted Teakettle
2007-08-15
ch 1,
abuseWonderful fic! It was very entertaining, and I enjoyed the dialogue and the interactions between Jack and Will, as it went well with their relationship in the canon. The characterizations and the writing style were well done too!

~ TET
Diana
2007-08-08
ch 1,
abuseVery well written. & quite amusing in places as well. Your use of descriptive vocabulary is certainly impressive & I found myself able to visualize the scene clearly through your excellent wordsmith skills. I quite enjoyed it & I thank you for the lovely read.

-- Diana
Jennifer Lynn Weston
2007-07-14
ch 1,
abuseI'd call that a durned good summary of Jack and Will's relationship by the end of the first movie.
Peace Like a River
2007-05-14
ch 1,
abuseYay, I love this! I think Jack and Will were very in character, and the banter you have between them is just perfect! I especially liked these lines...



Jack about-faced and held up a rigid forefinger between his frown and that on Will's face. "Boy, have I ever led you astray?"

Will narrowed his eyes. "Frequently."

Jack paused, studied his extended finger, and then lengthened his gaze to Will's face. "Let me rephrase. Have I ever led you into circumstances from which you were not fully capable of extricating yourself?"



And I also love how they end up having that great swordfight, working together like they did at the end of the first movie! One comment I do have, though, is that Jack's letter to Will seemed just a tad wordy. But only a tad. Good job, this is going in my favorites!
BelleMarie
2005-12-26
ch 1,
abuseWell done! Your use of language is exquisite, and your characterizations are dead-on!
Rogue-Pirate
2005-12-26
ch 1,
abuse"Such a lovely place you've chosen, Jack," Will murmured. "This is undoubtedly where Hell takes its holidays."

LOL...no doubt mate, I've no doubt at all that this is true...

Jack about-faced and held up a rigid forefinger between his frown and that on Will's face. "Boy, have I ever led you astray?"
Will narrowed his eyes. "Frequently."

Again, LOL. Well written, I can just see Jacks face...brillaint!

This is good. Ta.
Rogue-pirate
Return to Top