Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Search
Reviews for: What Is and What Will Never Be
dahan 8/19/06 . chapter 1
fififolle posted this a rec on Central. Hard to believe I missed it before _

*sigh* It's just sad! It is believable though, especially the part where he bites his tounge (something he never does) before he gets too far in talking to her. It's very bittersweet.
Porthos1013 1/15/06 . chapter 1
Gah! No fair making me cry, especially since I'm sitting here compiling a playlist of sad McWeir songs, in mourning for the fact that TPTB have obviously given up on my favorite pairing... :(
Aimee5 1/12/06 . chapter 1
Oh, I love the idea, very good. I've always really liked the idea of seeing the Sheppard/Weir relationship through the eyes of other people, and this is perfect.
Wile 1/9/06 . chapter 1
ooh, ouch! poor Rodney. Excellently written though. Thanks for sharing!
Hananian 1/8/06 . chapter 1
gotta say I agree with Fifi. :( Poor Rodney. But that is so accurate for how they're acting with any hint of McWeir for season 2. *sigh*

Very well written, and sadly, it seems quite accurate. Well done.
mate 1/8/06 . chapter 1
very nice story.
Akanan 1/7/06 . chapter 1
Ouch! Almost makes me feel bad for Rodney. Almost...
fififolle 1/7/06 . chapter 1
Perhaps the most devastatingly perfect Rodney fic I have ever read. Just makes your heart break. Dangnabbit, it ain't fair. Don't worry Rodney, we all love you! I still think you should have called it "Just kick him in the shin and be done" *sniff* I was afraid SWAMA meant that...
AniLuLu 1/7/06 . chapter 1
OMG I love this. I'm so glad I can now read Atlatis fics and know what the crap is going on P. This was great, and I love the emotion it portrays. Can't wait to read some more of this stuff!

-Love Always-
Fanwoman 1/7/06 . chapter 1
That was just so sad! They really seem to be doing their best to squelch all possibility of m/w this season, huh? But it's *highly* probable a smart, intelligent woman would like you, Rodney; a lesser woman couldn't handle you!
Return to Top