 rukiaichigo15chappy 2009-07-18 . chapter 1wow .. i really cry, |
 Ningen Demonai 2009-07-08 . chapter 1You are a terrible person and I'm going to bawl in this corner here. But more seriously, that was a very well-written piece. Heartbreaking, but all the more beautiful for it. You'll excuse me if I concoct ridiculous and impossible happy endings for it in my head, though. |
 GothicAngel09 2009-05-16 . chapter 1I cannot believe out of all the times I've read this(must be at least a half a dozen),I have never reviewed! For that,I truly apologize.This story is amazing!It is so well written and brings out so many emotions in the reader.Every time I read this one I love it more and more.I did have a question though,something that just came to me.When Shinichi was walking to Ran's house,he was dressed in white and was carrying white roses.White is the color for funerals in Japan(at least that's what I've heard)That was the part where he died,was that intentional?Just asking,great job on the fic! |
 Bloody Waterfalls 2009-01-04 . chapter 1Just amazing. It was perfect, especially if you listen to the song at the same time. :) I loved it. |
 kilala fae 2008-07-14 . chapter 1curious...did ran die in the end? i have read and re-read several times and i still can't seem to figure it out. or is it just one of those endings that is open to interpretation? |
 faanzzz 2008-06-04 . chapter 1 this is the most stuppid story i've ever read... i'm crying my butt off... :'(... |
 Runaway Soul 2008-04-07 . chapter 1I've just reread this and yet it's still as beautiful as before. It's wonderful! (And I can't believe I cried at the same part I did before, that is, when she visits his grave...) |
 chocolatefudgecake 2007-12-26 . chapter 1(Sigh) It was beautiful. The story was absolutely beautiful and it tugged my heart so much. I guess in the end you could say I was pot full of different emotions bubbling in me. Hope you make more stories like this (although not necessarily sad and angst). :D
I praise you. n_n |
 Peeka-chan 2007-12-26 . chapter 1Aww, so sad, yet cute. T.T |
 Ran-dezvous 2007-09-07 . chapter 1It's been more than a year since I first read this, and I'm only giving it a review (and adding it to my faves) now. I couldn't resist rereading it, and it still was as touching as ever. *huggles the fic*
Oh, and I recommended this to someone who wanted to translate Detective Conan fanfics to Spanish. I hope you don't mind. XD
Wishing for more Shin/Ran fics from you!
P.S. I added you to my f-list in LJ. Once again, I hope you don't mind. *smiles* |
 Viridian 2007-04-28 . chapter 1That's so ... tragic and bittersweet. It was hard to read because it was just so terribly, powerfully sad, but I'm glad I read it anyway. An angst warning would have been nice though ... *sniff*. |
 Animefangirl2007 2007-02-24 . chapter 1OMG it was so sad that I cried. I cannot believe he was alive!! The story was sad but the ending was cute. I really liked the story! |
 Moon-kun 2007-02-24 . chapter 1This story is truly commendable. I shed a few tears in the part when Ran was screaming at Shinichi's grave, calling him an idiot. Those kinds of things exist in almost every soap opera or something (you know...when someone dies and they express there love through a sort of hatred for leaving this world so early), and yet I think I almost always like them.
I would say that in my observations, you have portrayed Ran as someone who loves Shinichi but marries someone else to hide her misery. Maybe there was something inside of her that made her give up waiting. It was only my interpretation, though. What was swimming in your head when you wrote this?
I also love the sweet dreams you put in the middle. It adds a really beautiful effect. Ran dancing with Shinichi through fields of flowers...she is an orchid, after all (her full name, if I am not mistaken means forest orchid). The fact that one could smell the fragrance of roses or something after she wakes up adds a sort of mysterious twist.
For me, "Wake up, Ran" might mean that Ran was shielding herself away, hiding in a fluffy deception, a wonderland. And yet she must face reality. Yes or no? The "wake up" thing at the end was depressing.
The story was really long, and I had a good time reading it. Probably the only reason why I didn't cry too much was because I kept pausing when I read it (you see, I was trying to hide from my mom who is making me do work), so the effect must have diminished through the stopping. My sister recommended this to me as the fic that "made people cry," and I'm really glad I read it! You're an awesome writer!
Sincerely,
Soundless Melody
PS: I'm terribly sorry for my choppy review. I'm not very good at writing reviews, you know, but I tried my best to say more than "Waah! I cried! This was good," so I hope it was good enough for you. |
 BlackMailer 2006-05-20 . chapter 1I...LOVE...YOUU! |
 RWT 2006-03-09 . chapter 1Lee: SOB!! Oh man, that was so sad and yet great!
RWT: Yes, dang sometimes I curse my "imaging" for letting me see very sad scenes so vividly. It feels as if I'm crying as Ran cried... Darn sad and beautiful... |