 Seylin 2008-03-05 . chapter 1One of the best bloody HP fics I have ever read. This was written amazingly and I loved every second ofit. |
 siriuslyblackxx 2007-08-14 . chapter 1yayy for happy endings! haha i really liked the beginning and middle too :) |
 Dishonorable 2007-08-08 . chapter 1Very good job! |
 Child of a Pineapple 2007-07-10 . chapter 1This was good! Great job! |
 rekahneko 2007-06-29 . chapter 1I love how Sirius transfigures the silver bullets into flowers and tosses them. Very fitting.
This story makes me wonder how Remus was able to survive the times without his friends. No wonder he looked so much older than he was, once Sirius finally did return.
Wonderfully written! |
 Potgenie 2006-12-15 . chapter 1I LOVE THIS FIC! You have a beautiful style of writing! It makes me sad to think of what is to come for Remus and Sirius after this fic (you know, in the books and all). The characterization is excellent! Great job! :) |
 Mighty Lord Moldy-Shorts 2006-05-05 . chapter 1Great story! Yours are good! :) |
 tehPurr 2006-01-14 . chapter 1That was so good. You're an excellent writer. Poor Remus. I feel so, so sorry for him! (Even though he's a fictional character and all.) Write more like this! |
 DiscombobulatedDrummer 2006-01-09 . chapter 1That was wonderfully done. You didn't rush it a bit! The characters really fit. Remus probably had a breakdown, similar to this, you know? GREAT JOB!
DD |
 Emma Raven Moony Grimm 2006-01-09 . chapter 1Loved it. Made me cry, though. Beautiful story |
 Leonew 2006-01-09 . chapter 1The characters matched very good with my idea of them. I really liked the story! I don't see how you've rushed the end since there was nothing more to add. Harmless roses seem like a good ending ;)
Leonie |
 LilJester 2006-01-08 . chapter 1this was really good. I don't think the ending was rushed at all, i actually liked how it slowly ended. Again, this was really good! |
 AnnaLangdon 2006-01-08 . chapter 1This was excellent. I, for one, am extremely glad you woke up with this idea! |
 Snickle-Gigger 2006-01-08 . chapter 1"(he had taken Muggle Studies for all of a year before deciding that he could learn all he wanted about Muggles by hexing Lily’s sister at King’s Cross Station at the beginning of term every year and watching her reaction)."
*puts on Comic Book Guy from "The Simpsons" voice*
Best. Fanfiction. Line. Ever.
It was interesting to note that Remus somewhat agreed with the anti-werewolf legislation, since he knew what he was capable of. A nice touch.
I rather liked that ending paragraph--it didn't seem rushed at all. It was a hell of a lot better than I could have done. :)
Excellent job! |