Deep and sad. Angsty.

I loved it. Keep on writing the way you do. I like how you made Sam's reactions. Very samlike.

:D

Really wonderful insight into Sam's thoughts after the episode. Well done! :)

Wow. I really like how you got into Sam's head with this. It's very well written.

WOW... I was rewatching "Faith"' and checked fanfiction to see if there where any tags or such that had to do with the episode. I found this, and even though I'm a Sammy girl, I couldn't help but love it! You wrote a strong, powerful one-shot. Angsty and a medley of other emotions made this fic very potent and poignant. Great job!

Absolutely believable. Yes, Sam WOULD have exchanged a stranger's life for his brother, even if he had known. And, yes, it would rip him up to know that.

Wow. What a beautiful fic. I love this ep and I think you've captured both Sam and Dean perfectly, especially given the seasons following. I'm also a Dean fan, BTW.

Thanks for writing!

Eleri

I badly speak English, therefore... Yes, I consider that Sam NEVER regretted that happens in "Faith." And, hell, yes if he knew that the life the Dean will cost, it all the same would arrive so.

this is so good!

See, see! NRFTW and Faith ... so similar!

Great introspective piece on Sam, and his selfishness.

And Dean's pretty selfish too - in the end! :)

Lovely fic

i know you were worried that it would come across as sam bashing but it didnt... I think it shows that he really would do anything for dean... great job

*blink*

Whoa, very powerful. Nice!

it amazes me how perfectly you have the boys. i'm a sammy-girl myself, so i don't like to see him in a cold/selfish light, but i think you really nailed that self-punishment streak. not to mention the whole brotherly love/sacrifice. awesome job.

O - that was good!

Hey, enjoyed this one, too. You obviously see Sam and Dean the same way I do as these were my thoughts on the subject. Nice job...I'm off to read more, lol.

Nicole

You know me and some others had this debate and I took the stance that even if Sam had have known he would have done "whatever it takes" to keep Dean alive. Now let me tell you that was a heated debate cause most everyone else were like no way but to me there was no way in hell Sam was gonna let Dean die not matter what it took. Im glad someone else thought about it too. Sam would dry up and blow away without Dean they are two halves of a whole. Great stroy really loved it.