Reviews for Farewell, My Love

Reviews For: Farewell, My Love

Beleth 2008-07-03 ch 1,	abuseThis is a very nice piece of writing here. It's even better because it deals with the character of Aegnor and Andreth. It's so sad that they never got together and this illustrates, very well, Aegnor's tragic position in knowing he is dying and will never see his love ever again. I do hope you write another story about either or both Aegnor and Andreth because they are written about often. >>Far away, a woman of the House of Beorn Do you mean "House of Beor"? Thanks for writing!
LifeIsRandom09 2008-01-30 ch 1,	abuse...runs to get tissues B-E-A-UTIFUL!
Feanathiel 2008-01-29 ch 1,	abuseYou have captured the tone beautifully...bittersweet.
Verity Kindle 2006-10-07 ch 1, anon.	abuseAw!! (sniffle)
Fainting Maid 2006-05-21 ch 1, anon.	abuseAn Aegnor story! There aren't nearly enough of them so please write more! I really like what you did with the little bit Tolkien gave. You dressed up the existing story nicely. And the counterpoint of the physical pain of the wounding and the spiritual pain of the seperation was very touching and sad.
Elfique 2006-02-05 ch 1,	abusevery well written and moving. I love the flashback to when he left. Its nice to see another Aegnor and Andreth fic, they are such a great Silm couple. Ive been planning my own for a while but i need a kick up the rear before i start writing hah.
Absent Poet 2006-02-04 ch 1, anon.	abuseI don't know what to say. This is well-written, but the premise and character behavior is a little predictable and weigh down your soaring words. The whole 'forbidden love' idea and the 'voodoo'-esque effect we see so often in ballads (where the fair maiden knows, even from miles away, that her true love is dead) have both been done. Your prose seems to have the potential to have given us a fresher look at the romance between Aegnor and Andreth and I am the first to say 'Don't give up on it.' There is, as I said, so much potential here. Though bogged down by cliches, this fanfic cuts straight to the bone and I don't doubt in the least that you could do it real justice. Keep up the good work, please; I'm just trying to be constructive.
Celegorm 2006-02-03 ch 1, anon.	abuseAs the sappy, love sick stuffs goes this is fair enough
The Battling Bard 2006-02-03 ch 1,	abuseThe Aegnor death scene has been done before, but this fic is still very good. Aegnor and Andreth is my favourite pairing. Maybe you could write a sequel in which they meet in Arda re-made as Finrod believed? That would be beyond wonderful.
epalladino 2006-02-03 ch 1,	abuseInteresting. It's not always easy to make such a nice story out of the "Silmarillion". Thanks, Beth Palladino

Return to Top