Share/Save/Bookmark
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Reviews For: Phoenix Song

Greencoatie
2007-10-06
ch 1,
abuseWell I thought I'd check out some of your other writings...
Whew am I pleasently ssurprised.
This was just lovely. The complete opposite of the fluff piece I just left. You've got some talent.

Thanks for writing and sharing.
Kin Pandun
2006-10-31
ch 1,
abuseWho from Lyra's world is in the Harry Potter-verse?

Thanks for writing,
Kin.
JediClaire
2006-06-23
ch 1,
abuseWow! Will you be doing any more stories along this idea? If you do I will read them!
Tindomiel
2006-03-03
ch 1,
abuseFantastic idea. Farfetched, given HP canon and evidence, but a well constructed AU none the less. The character of Dumbledore was well played, and Fawkes was a splendid creation, with a wonderful character.
Bagge
2006-02-16
ch 1,
abuseBeautiful. A wonderful take on Dumbeldore. He and Fawkes (and Voldermort and Nagi) are close, but I never imagined they were this close. Given that they don't seem to be close to each other all the time, it seems likely that they have been going through something similar to the witches initiation, but why not? You really don't leave any lose ends. The stone would explain how he keeps alive.

Those silvery intstruments described by Rowling could just as easely be something from Jordan collage. Nice touch. In all, a very well written and highly imaginative story.
Taedere-Belletrist
2006-02-05
ch 1,
abuseWOAH! I love this! I haven't read an x over of His Dark Materials and HP before and you have done such a magnificient job! I love how you characterized Fawkes! I hope you don't mind me putting this cute fic in my C2. Peace and Inspiration T-B
lunefin
2006-02-05
ch 1,
abuseWow. A dark materials and harry potter crossover. Giggles. I like the way your mind works.
Sabia
2006-02-04
ch 1,
abuseIngenious... lovely idea. Possibility of coninuation? Don't you think Harry and Will would get along well?
Magpie Poet
2006-02-03
ch 1,
abuseawesome. can't picture where you're gonna run with this, and can't wait to find out :D

one little nitpick, aren't daemons supposed to be of the opposite sex?
Kat Hawkins
2006-02-03
ch 1,
abuseaw. That was sweet.
Return to Top