|
|
| Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search | Login Register Extras |
| FelicityOConnor 2007-09-30 ch 1, | abuseOMG WHAT HAPPENED TO FELICITY O'CONNOR! I NEED TO KNOW, THIS AFFECTS MY VERY EXISTENCE! |
| MrsNott 2007-09-15 ch 7, | abuseOh my! I lovbe this story!! Please do update or rewrite it soon! |
| Owl Emporium 2007-08-31 ch 8, | abuseContinue soon please! I loved this, it made me almost cry...but i loved it! Please, continue now! :] Angelica |
| coco162_2006 2007-02-27 ch 8, anon. | abuseKEEP WRITING PLEASE! |
| iluvlilnjames 2007-01-30 ch 8, | abuseU CANT DISCONTINUE THIS STORY! I HAVE BEN CRYING MY EYES OUT MAN! ITS HURTS!...please please continue...i beg you...please? |
| Broadway L0VE 2007-01-07 ch 7, | abuseHeylo. Random Rose. Just droppin in to say hi. Love your story. Anyways, here's another review to add to your collection. -Me. |
| Maraudess 2006-12-13 ch 8, | abusereelly good story, please hurry and finish! |
| KrElric 2006-09-19 ch 8, | abuseAw I love this fic!! Is so nice and well written, besides it makes you think. I love depressing things (I'm a sort of a masochist in that sense) but it's rerally lovely! I hope you post soon "losing her wings" because I'm dying seperatedly to know what comes next!! |
| Lily's Petal 2006-08-10 ch 8, | abuseit was good why did you atop? i was getting really anxious because i wanted to know what was going to happen |
| dracosbabygrl 2006-08-03 ch 8, | abusedamn. lily is antisocial but i love this fic! |
| Akt5us 2006-08-02 ch 8, | abuseI can't wait to read the new story! |
| Bucky Katt Rocks 2006-08-02 ch 8, | abuseThis is an interesting story, you can definitely go somewhere with it. I'll keep my eye out for the re-write. And just as a note: Lily would not be manically depressed, because that is having extreme highs and lows. She is probably more chronic depression, cuz she's always low. At least, that's how I thought you wrote her. (I took a psych class once, so I'm not an authority, but I thought it might help your story). |
| Yankee 2006-08-02 ch 8, anon. | abuseIf you dont wanna continue writing,just stop but dont fill the pages. Your story started really good but slowly lost its charm. Try to put some more creativity into it! |
| icedance 2006-06-29 ch 7, anon. | abuseAre you going to finish the story soon? Becasue if you aren't, then i need to know so that i'm not wasting my time. |
| Folk 2006-06-24 ch 1, | abuseHmm...interesting. (This is from the evil mind that brought you "A Hogwarts Autumn", which I see you at least attempted to salvage...haha sorry about that) ;). First of all, the mechanics are fine. The sentence structure is fine. The problem is the characterization. I think Lily is a much stronger character than this (Harry doesn't get everything from his dad, y'know); this reminds me strongly of Cho-who-cried-all-the-time. I do love the descriptions, specifically of the silver lily on the diary and things like that, but I think that you would be better suited to write Lily as a strong character who just gets fed up with all the other girls' teasing etc. until one day she FINALLY breaks down and cries. Also...she's known--and hated--James since at least 5th year, so maybe you could edit this chapter so that she suddenly sees him as someone potentially nice? Good situation and all if worked on a bit! (Revising...the wosrt part of writing...gah). Good luck! Ciao, Ivy :) |