Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: Old Soldiers Never Die - Page 1 of 137
The Sound Shaman
2009-11-21 . chapter 6
very nice story, but it's ridiculous to say that there have been few advances in firearms in the past century. in 1909 did they have guns with an effective range of 2 kilometers which fired 60 rounds per minute? Did they have sniper rifles that could kill people from a mile away? did they have shotgun shells loaded with napalm? no.
MajinBakaHentai
2009-11-17 . chapter 26
This has been a good story. I have to say I loved the Kiwi guys doing a Haka before the big battle - I may be from the other side of the Tasman, but still it's damn cool.
alkkhes
2009-11-15 . chapter 5
love it but what kind of guns do the soldiers use?
alkkhes
2009-11-15 . chapter 1
love it so far question what type of gun was it?
texasfaith89
2009-11-12 . chapter 26
Very cool story! It almost slipped into crack!fic territory a few times, but overall I thought that the balance of humor and seriousness was pretty good. You didn't let it get too dark or too ridiculous. Loved the whole concept of bringing in the old squib soldiers! I always enjoy stories that have Harry defeat Voldie using muggle methods. All in all, a fabulously entertaining story! Thanks for sharing!
Basill
2009-11-10 . chapter 26
Amazing story! I hope you ether have or will have a sequel!
Dekosh
2009-11-08 . chapter 26
One of the best HP storys I have read.
petros308
2009-10-30 . chapter 26
Top notch! It was a great read and caused some chuckles and hand rubbing on my part. AU for sure but in a good way! Harry did call the CPO chief twice though, and I would of loved for him to of called Harry "skipper" at least once.
Tigerman
2009-10-19 . chapter 2
Hehe! I know I'm only at the second chapter, but I had to tell you that: the idea of making an actual squib army is unique and priceless! The age average though make me think of this barbarian character in a Terry Pratchett book, Cohan, the 88 years old barbarian...Still he kicked asses so I'm eager to see what you do with your gold age club!

Tigerman
noylj
2009-10-17 . chapter 6
I don't mind a martini (though the maumaus might laugh about that rifle), but a Webley and the .455 is rather useless. Should have a 1911, but not British enough. I like the BHP, but the 9x19 is only good for piercing very light armor/shields and making little holes. The Brits have never really bothered to field a decent sidearm. Really think Harry should swallow his pride and get a 1911. Just don't see a .455 at, what, 650fps as being of much use except very close up like on Privet Dr.
Ironc
2009-10-07 . chapter 26
.
Es ist einfach aufheiternd wie du schreibst. Bitte schreibe weiter so.

mfg
dein total begeisterter Iron

PS: read with help from: h t t p : / / t r a n s l a t e. g o o g l e. c o m
.
JoAnn
2009-09-20 . chapter 26
I had read this story quite a while ago and loved it then. Well I just sat and read it through a second time and although nothing had change it was better the second time round. I'll wait a while and see what I think on the third, but I have no doubt at how well this story it written, nor how much it has captured my interest! Love it and always will! (p.s. it means even more this time because my cousin is a Sapper in Afganistan right now, so the British military is near and dear)
WhiteElfElder
2009-09-17 . chapter 26
This was well written and I enjoyed it. I liked seeing the combination of the two "worlds" into a nicely working cohesion. Wouldn't mind reading the further tales of this line.
Orchamus
2009-09-12 . chapter 26
Hot damn good shit.
Orchamus
2009-09-11 . chapter 3
Hell yeah, Tonks needs to join.
Return to Top