|
|
| Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search | Login Register Extras |
| Smiley Smackdown 2008-06-26 ch 4, | abuse-_-GASP! please update soon!-_- |
| elecktrum 2006-10-09 ch 4, | abuseI greatly enjoyed everything about this story - the title, the characterization, the interaction between the siblings, and the very intriguing storyline you've started. I'm very curious about the resolution of Edmund's dreams and I'm not surprised that Peter is thinking of enlisting in the army. It's quite fitting and I could see him willing to defend England as ardently as he defended Narnia. I look forward to the next chapter! |
| Boleyn 2006-09-06 ch 4, | abuseGreat story, please update soon |
| imakeladrygirl 2006-08-18 ch 4, | abuseThis is really great! Please update soon! |
| sandysoul 2006-05-04 ch 4, | abuseHi Jenn, I think you're characterization of Susan is great! It's something I never thought of, but you're absolutely right - Susan's denial of Narnia could very well have started because she couldn't go there and didn't want to deal with the pain. Beautiful. I liked Ed and Peter's interaction all through this chapter too. Great job. |
| htbthomas 2006-05-03 ch 4, | abuseWell, hey, this is turning into a fascinating and thought-provoking story. You really have some great ideas. I think the conversation between the brothers seems so natural, especially considering their shared experiences. And I agree with another reviewer that Edmund rocks in this story. He has definitely matured a lot. Keep up the good work, buddy o' mine. |
| Rosa Cotton 2006-05-02 ch 4, | abuseWhoa, Peter might enlist?! No, I'm sure Edmund isn't very thrilled with that piece of information. *sigh* Ed and Peter discussing about whether the White Witch died or not or was brought back to life, reminded me of having the same discussion with fellow Narnia fans. Touchy subject. Anyway! Another great chapter. I like how you have written Peter and Ed. Please update soon; I need to know what happens next!! |
| Rosa Cotton 2006-05-02 ch 3, | abuseWow, what a story you are weaving, Jenn1! And this chapter was very interesting. Edmund sees Rilian before Eustace and Jill are called to Narnia...VERY interesting. And -- at least in his dream -- the Green Lady is Jadis; hm. So many questions... ;-) Wonderfully written. |
| Kelsey Estel the TolkieNarn... 2006-05-01 ch 4, | abusePeter's fought in enough wars! I'm sure the theory is basically the same, even if the weapons aren't. He'll be better prepared than any of the privates that go out there. He, at least, has been to war before. He's practically a veteran! It would be wrong of him, knowing what a great soldier he can be, not to enlist. He fought for the freedom of the Narnians, can't he fight to free the jewish people who are also sons and daughters of Adam and Eve? Now, I'm not saying that it would be wrong of Peter to decide NOT to go to war, Aslan knows he's seen enough of it, but I don't see anything wrong with him choosing to enlist. He'll probably be drafted before then, anyway, if he's over 18 (and, in college, he might be.) Poor Edmund! I like how you turn the Green Witch, who we never really learned anything about, into Jadis. You make a valid point, if one group talked of bringing her back, what's to say another group didn't actually do it? Perhaps there was a dwarf who idolized Nikabrik and wanted to get revenge on Caspian through Jadis? But, Silver Chair probably has nothing to do with your plot. Anyway, it was a just a random dream of Ed's, right? More soon! |
| Sentimental Star 2006-05-01 ch 4, | abuse::grins:: Well, as promised, I'm reviewing for this chapter. You already know my main thoughts on the bulk of it, but I don't believe I mentioned that I liked the fact that you had Peter watching Edmund when Nikabrik and the Hag and the Wolf were speaking about the White Witch. That was yet another very nice touch to add to this story. Pleased to see that you're following my suggestions, and still like this chapter a great deal. ::grins again:: Take care and I'm looking forward to the next chapter! Best Regards, Sentimental Star |
| janeyjane: screaming yaio h... 2006-05-01 ch 4, anon. | abusei like verry much. even when the older pevencies weren't in the srotys any more thats how i imagened them from the snipits of information given. |
| TimeMage0955 2006-05-01 ch 4, | abuseNO PETER NO! YOU WILL NOT ENLIST! YOU WILL NOT! Susan, stop forgetting! Rememeber Narnia! REMEMBER! And just to get this off my chest, GO EDMUND! HE ROCKS! And so do you! Plz update rlly soon! This chapter was awesome, so update rlly soon! |
| jjonahjameson 2006-04-25 ch 3, | abuseGreat dream! Very eerie and weird. :-) |
| TimeMage0955 2006-04-22 ch 3, | abuseOH creepy! I had a dream like that once, and trust me, it was scary. Anyway, i am so glad that you updated, so update RLLY SOON! Not in a month or two. BYE! |
| Kelsey Estel the TolkieNarn... 2006-04-21 ch 3, | abuseWhoa. Edmund is now clairvoyant! I like the part between Peter and Susan. I like this so far! I hope you add more to this story, I'm interested in where you take it. KelsE |